- Q3 Results: Cleveland-Cliffs reported Q3 sales of $4.73 billion, up 3.6% from $4.57 billion a year ago marketscreener.com, narrowly missing analysts’ $4.90 billion estimate.
- Tariff-Driven Demand: The company cited President Trump’s 50% steel tariffs as reviving U.S. demand for its auto-grade steel marketscreener.com. CEO Lourenco Goncalves said, “As a result of this new trade environment, we have won new and growing supply arrangements with all major automotive [OEMs]” 1 .
- Rare-Earth Push: CLF announced plans to explore its Michigan and Minnesota mines for rare-earth minerals. Management noted this would “align Cleveland-Cliffs with the broader national strategy for critical material independence,” echoing the Biden administration’s push for domestic critical minerals marketscreener.com 2 .
- Stock Rally: CLF shares jumped ~19% premarket on Oct. 20 to about $15.87, settling around $15.50 (up ~16% intraday) tradingview.com stockanalysis.com. The stock has climbed roughly 42% YTD tradingview.com after this surge.
- Analyst Outlook: Despite today’s rally, analysts remain cautious. The consensus “Buy” rating comes with an average 12-month price target near $11.31 – about 27% below current levels stockanalysis.com. Many see CLF as a beneficiary of tariffs, but warn that falling steel prices or demand could pressure profits ahead.
Tariff-Fueled Growth in Q3
Cleveland-Cliffs’ Q3 results revealed a tariff-fueled bump in sales. Revenue rose 3.6% year-over-year to $4.73 billion, thanks in part to the 50% tariff on imported steel imposed earlier this year marketscreener.com. The company shipped 4.0 million net tons of steel (vs 3.8 M last year), reflecting stronger orders from automakers investorshub.advfn.com. However, CLF still posted a GAAP net loss of $251 million ($0.51/share), nearly unchanged from a year ago marketscreener.com. Adjusted loss was $0.45/share, in line with forecasts. Management emphasized that new long-term contracts with Detroit automakers (Ford, GM, etc.) were secured under the new trade rules. As CEO Goncalves noted, domestic demand has “recovered for automotive-grade steel made in the USA” thanks to the Trump administration’s “new trade environment” marketscreener.com investorshub.advfn.com. In short, the tariffs are helping CLF grab market share at home.
Meanwhile, CLF also signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with a global steelmaker to leverage its U.S. capacity marketscreener.com gurufocus.com. The company reiterated cost-saving measures and trimmed its full-year outlook: it now expects 2025 capex of about $525 M (down from $600 M) and SG&A ~$550 M (down from $575 M) tradingview.com. Such discipline is meant to preserve cash, especially since steel prices have started to moderate.
Rare-Earth Strategy Amid Trade Tensions
In a major strategic shift, Cleveland-Cliffs is betting on critical minerals too. The company announced it will explore for rare-earth elements (REEs) at its U.S. mining sites. This move comes as the U.S. government seeks to reduce dependence on China for REEs – essential for EVs, wind turbines and defense. Goncalves told investors that “the renewed importance of rare earths has driven us to re-focus on this potential opportunity at our upstream mining assets” news.bloomberglaw.com. He added that identifying REEs “align[s] Cleveland-Cliffs with the broader national strategy for critical material independence” 3 .
This announcement coincides with a broader trade-rhetoric backdrop: earlier this month China tightened export controls on several rare-earth metals ts2.tech, prompting U.S. officials to consider even higher tariffs on Chinese goods in retaliation ts2.tech. CLF’s push to find domestic REEs is therefore being viewed by investors as timely. (Other U.S. miners, like MP Materials, also jumped on the China news ts2.tech.) Cleveland-Cliffs’ exploration is in preliminary stages, but analysts say it could eventually add a new revenue stream if viable deposits are confirmed.
Stock Reaction and Analyst Take
Investors cheered the dual announcements. CLF stock spiked ~19% in premarket trading on Oct. 20 tradingview.com, and continued to trade near those levels during the day. At $15.50 (as of Oct. 20’s open stockanalysis.com), the shares sit well above the average analyst target. Remarkably, this jump brought CLF to a roughly 41.7% gain year-to-date tradingview.com. Market participants noted that CLF’s rally outpaced peers in steel and materials. For context, competitor Nucor (NUE) gained more modestly after reporting results, highlighting CLF’s unique tariff-and-REE narrative.
Despite the enthusiasm, Wall Street’s consensus remains cautious. According to StockAnalysis, the 11 covering analysts maintain a “Buy” consensus but with an average 1-year target of only $11.31 stockanalysis.com (range $3.91 – $17.00). Several brokerages (JPMorgan, BofA, Wells Fargo) have “Hold” or modest “Buy” ratings, noting that CLF’s profits are still in the red and reliant on a favourable tariff regime. An analyst from Goldman Sachs recently reiterated a Strong Buy but only modestly raised his target from $13 to $15 4 .
Forecast: Many analysts expect CLF to remain volatile. If steel tariffs stay in place and global auto demand holds up, CLF could continue to outperform lower-cost or non-domestic producers. However, if tariffs are rolled back or if automotive production falters, the rally could lose steam. Given current sentiment and a full-year EBITDA forecast roughly flat to Q4, CLF’s short-term price target (consensus ~$12) likely lags the market price stockanalysis.com. Still, some see room for the stock to stay elevated as long as the tariff-backed trading environment persists. Investors will be watching CLF’s next moves in capex, cost cuts and any concrete rare-earth findings, which Goncalves believes could be as transformative for critical minerals as past measures were for steel marketscreener.com 5 .
Sources: Cleveland-Cliffs Q3 earnings release and related filings tradingview.com; Dow Jones/WSJ coverage marketscreener.com marketscreener.com; Bloomberg Law (via Reuters) on rare-earth exploration news.bloomberglaw.com; trading commentary (Reuters/TS2/MarketScreener) on tariffs and stock movement ts2.tech tradingview.com; StockAnalysis (TipRanks) analyst data 6 .
