- Guidance Cut: BMW has slashed its 2025 profit forecast, now expecting a slight decline in pre-tax earnings versus previous guidance of flat growth. The automaker narrowed its Automotive EBIT margin outlook to 5–6% (from 5–7%) for the year [1] [2], citing weaker demand in China and delayed tariff relief as the key reasons.
- China & Tariffs Hit Earnings: The company’s surprise profit warning blames two main factors – a slowdown in China’s car sales and a setback in U.S.-EU trade tariffs. BMW’s sales in China have underperformed expectations (down ~11% year-on-year for Jan–Sept) and the company must financially support its Chinese dealers amid reduced bank commissions [3] [4]. Meanwhile, planned U.S. tariff refunds (from a deal to cut import duties from 10% to 0%) are now delayed into 2026, removing an expected boost to 2025 results [5] [6]. BMW halved its free cash flow projection for the auto division to >€2.5 billion(from over €5 billion) due to the tariff timing [7].
- Stock Plunge: Investors reacted sharply. BMW’s share price plunged as much as 7% intraday on Oct 8 (and over 9% at one point) after the warning [8] [9]. The stock fell from the high €80s to the upper €70s, erasing about €5–€7 billion in market value, before stabilizing around €80 by October 9 [10]. Rival Mercedes-Benz stock also dropped ~3–4% in sympathy, as it likewise reported weaker China sales and tariff pressures [11].
- Analyst Reactions: Several analysts struck a cautious tone but noted the news was not wholly unexpected. UBSlowered its price target for BMW from €103 to €95 but kept a “Buy” rating, saying BMW remains better positioned than competitors on investment cycle, cash returns and upcoming models [12]. J.P. Morgan and RBC analysts argued that the China slump is a bigger concern than the temporary tariff issue, emphasizing the need for BMW to stabilize volumes and pricing in that crucial market [13] [14]. Jefferies also maintained a bullish stance (Buy) with a €92 target, despite the near-term profit setback [15].
- Outlook: BMW will report full third-quarter results on November 5, 2025, which investors hope will shed more light on these challenges [16]. The company expects to recoup the “high three-digit million” euros in tariffs it overpaid – but only in 2026 [17]. BMW’s management remains optimistic that Chinese demand will gradually recover in the longer term once current headwinds pass [18]. However, experts note that China’s auto market is increasingly dominated by strong domestic EV players like BYD and Nio, which are eroding foreign brands’ share [19]. This competitive reality, alongside geopolitical trade risks, will shape BMW’s strategy and performance going forward.
BMW Lowers Forecast Amid China Slowdown and Tariff Setback
BMW AG stunned investors this week by issuing an ad-hoc profit warning and cutting its financial guidance for 2025. Late on Tuesday (Oct 7), the Munich-based luxury automaker announced that its profit before tax will likely decline slightly this year – a reversal from its earlier pledge of keeping earnings flat versus 2024 [20]. Just hours after reporting a rise in Q3 vehicle deliveries, BMW admitted it must dial back expectations for profitability in light of mounting challenges [21]. In an official statement, the company trimmed its Automotive segment’s expected EBIT margin to 5–6% (down from the prior 5–7% range) and warned that group pre-tax income will fall by around 5–10% year-on-year instead of remaining stable [22] [23].
Two external factors forced BMW’s hand. First is the continued weakness in China, BMW’s largest market. Demand in China has been softer than hoped – BMW’s unit sales in China actually fell slightly (-0.4%) in Q3 and are down over 11% for the first nine months of 2025 [24]. The automaker failed to achieve its targeted growth in China despite overall global sales rising, and it now anticipates lower sales volumes in China for Q4 as well [25]. BMW also revealed it is spending to prop up its dealers in China: a cut in commissions by local banks on auto financing has hurt dealer profitability, so BMW is stepping in with financial support [26]. These trends underscore how China’s economic slowdown and fierce local competition are undercutting BMW’s performance. In fact, domestic Chinese carmakers are rapidly gaining ground – BYD overtook Volkswagen as China’s top-selling auto brand in 2023, and foreign automakers from VW to Mercedes-Benz have seen their EV sales stall as nimble Chinese rivals steal market share [27]. This puts intense pressure on BMW’s China business, which traditionally has been a key profit engine.
The second blow to BMW’s outlook comes from international trade friction. The company had been counting on relief from U.S.–EU auto tariffs this year, but those savings will come too late to help 2025. Under a transatlantic trade agreement framework, import duties on cars and parts were supposed to drop from 10% to 0%, retroactive to August 1, 2025 [28]. BMW, which exports a range of SUVs from its U.S. plant to Europe and ships European-made cars to the U.S., stood to benefit significantly [29]. However, the implementation of the tariff cuts has been delayed, and bureaucratic holdups mean refunds on tariffs already paid won’t arrive until 2026 [30]. “Contrary to assumptions made to date, the BMW Group now assumes that reimbursements of customs duties totaling a high three-digit million figure will not be received in 2025,” the company stated in its guidance update [31]. In other words, BMW paid hundreds of millions of euros in tariffs this year that it will only get back next year, leaving a hole in the 2025 profit and cash flow.
Financially, the impact is substantial. BMW slashed its free cash flow forecast for the Automotive segment by half – now expecting just over €2.5 billion in 2025, versus more than €5 billion previously [32]. The reduced cash generation is directly tied to the postponed tariff refunds and softer China revenues. BMW also cut its target for Automotive return on capital employed (RoCE) to 8–10%, from an original 9–13% [33], reflecting the profitability squeeze. The company maintained its dividend payout policy (30–40% of net income) and ongoing share buyback program [34], signaling confidence that the setback is temporary. Nonetheless, as BMW acknowledged, these developments “wirken sich spürbar auf die Geschäftsentwicklung aus” – they are materially affecting business performance [35].
Stock Slides as Investors React and Auto Sector Feels the Heat
BMW’s profit warning immediately spooked the market, sending its stock into a tailspin. When trading opened on Wednesday, October 8, BMW shares plunged, falling as much as 6–7% during the session [36]. At its lows, the stock was down over 9% from the prior day’s close [37] – marking one of BMW’s sharpest single-day drops in years. The share price, which had been in the mid-€80s earlier in the week, briefly traded in the high €70s before regaining some ground. By Thursday Oct 9, BMW hovered around €80–81 per share [38] [39], still roughly 7–8% below its pre-warning level. This selloff wiped out roughly €6 billion in market capitalization in two days. It also pared BMW’s year-to-date stock gains; as of Oct 9, the shares were only up about 2% for 2025 [40], whereas just a week earlier they had been up nearly 10% YTD.
The shock from BMW’s announcement reverberated across the European auto sector. Investors extrapolated BMW’s issues to other carmakers, especially those exposed to China. Shares of Mercedes-Benz fell about 3.5% on Wednesday [41], and Volkswagen stock also dipped, amid concerns that similar China-driven headwinds could hit their results. Notably, Mercedes had reported a 12% plunge in its own Q3 unit sales (largely due to China weakness) on the same day BMW posted a 9% gain in deliveries [42], highlighting how varied the performance is within the sector. Auto industry indices were in the red following BMW’s guidance cut. As one market analysis noted, BMW’s warning dragged down auto stocks globally, reminding investors that China’s economic woes and trade policy shifts are still major risk factors for the industry [43]. U.S. automakers with big China sales or exposure to trade tariffs also saw their stock prices under pressure after the news [44].
From a broader perspective, BMW’s stumble contributed to a more cautious mood in European equity markets mid-week. The German DAX index – in which BMW is a heavyweight component – lost ground on Oct 8, underperforming slightly as BMW’s drop weighed on the index. “Die BMW-Aktie reagiert deutlich, der Kurs fiel am Mittwoch um 6,4 Prozent,” wrote WirtschaftsWoche, noting the stock’s steep decline and adding that Mercedes’ shares, while down, fell less sharply [45]. The episode reinforced the fragility of the global auto rebound story: after enjoying strong post-pandemic demand, carmakers are now grappling with a Chinese market cooldown and geopolitical uncertainties (tariffs, supply chain issues). BMW’s predicament exemplifies how quickly sentiment can turn when a pillar of the industry issues a warning.
Analyst Views: “Focus on China” as Banks Trim Targets but Stay Bullish
In the wake of BMW’s profit warning, financial analysts and bank research teams hurried to update their models – and their messages to investors were a mix of caution and guarded optimism. Several analysts pointed out that BMW’s announcement, while disappointing, validated concerns that had already been on their radar. “Analysten hatten bereits mit einer vorsichtigeren Prognose gerechnet,” observed Focus Online, suggesting the guidance cut was not a complete surprise to the market [46]. Nevertheless, the magnitude of the China slowdown and the tariff delay prompted revisions to forecasts and price targets across the board.
UBS was among the first to react. The Swiss bank’s auto analyst Patrick Hummel lowered his 12-month price target for BMW stock from €103 to €95 following the news, but crucially he maintained a “Buy”recommendation [47]. In a note to clients, Hummel said he is sticking with the Buy call “trotz der überraschenden Gewinnwarnung” – despite the unexpected profit warning – because he sees BMW as fundamentally strong. He argued the company is “better positioned” than competitors in key areas like its investment cycle, cash returns, and next-generation models, and thus should be able to weather the current challenges [48]. However, UBS did acknowledge the hit from China’s woes: Hummel cut his earnings-per-share estimates for BMW by up to 17% for 2025–2027 to reflect the “darkened” profit outlook in China [49]. In essence, UBS’s view is that BMW’s long-term strategy remains on track, but near-term earnings will be lower than previously thought due to the Chinese market softness.
Analysts at J.P. Morgan and RBC Capital Markets concurred that the China factor looms largest. RBC’s team said the U.S. tariff refund delay was “disappointing” – they had expected BMW might avoid major trade fallout – but they emphasized that China’s demand trends are the more critical variable for BMW’s future [50] [51]. JPMorgan analysts wrote that more important than the tariff timing will be BMW’s “ability to stabilise the volume momentum and pricing power in China in FY26, which will ultimately ensure the longer term competitiveness of the group” [52]. In other words, investors should watch whether BMW can stop the slide in China – potentially via new EV models or pricing adjustments – as that will determine the company’s earnings trajectory beyond this year. On the tariff issue, both UBS and JPMorgan essentially advised not to overreact: the consensus was that the customs refund is a timing issue, not a permanent loss, so it doesn’t fundamentally change BMW’s valuation [53] [54]. The cash will likely arrive in 2026, and margins should normalize once those one-off costs are recuperated.
Other banks echoed a balanced take. Jefferies affirmed its bullish stance on BMW despite the guidance cut – the investment bank reiterated its Buy rating and kept a €92 price target, according to an index-radar analysis cited by Focus [55]. Jefferies analysts seem to view the profit warning as a bump in the road rather than a detour from BMW’s longer-term course. Meanwhile, some analysts have pointed out positives like BMW’s robust electric vehicle rollout and strong order books in Europe and North America, arguing these can partially offset the Chinese weakness (though BMW did not alter its EV sales targets, any such details will likely come in the quarterly report). Overall, no major brokerage downgraded BMW to a “Sell” on this news – a sign that insiders see this as a manageable setback. The stock’s pullback, in fact, could be an opportunity; UBS’s €95 target implies roughly 18% upside from current levels [56], indicating confidence that BMW’s fundamentals remain solid once external storms pass. Still, the near term sentiment is undoubtedly cautious. As one German media commentary put it, “nach der Feier kommt der Kater” – after the party comes the hangover – suggesting BMW’s investors are now coming to grips with the risks that had been brewing (China, tariffs, etc.) even amid this year’s earlier auto industry euphoria.
Outlook: Challenges Ahead, but Long-Term Fundamentals Intact
Looking forward, BMW faces a delicate balancing act: navigating the immediate headwinds without losing sight of its strategic goals. The company has already signaled that it expects conditions to improve in 2026 – notably through the recovery of tariff costs and a hoped-for stabilization in China’s economy [57]. In the long term, BMW executives remain optimistic about Chinese demand for its luxury vehicles, especially as it expands its lineup of electric models tailored to local tastes. However, the competitive landscape in China has permanently evolved, and BMW will need to sharpen its game. Homegrown Chinese brands, often offering high-tech EVs at lower prices, are not only capturing mass-market buyers but also encroaching on the premium segment. For example, Chinese EV makers now command over half of China’s auto market, and even premium offerings from Nio, Xpeng, and BYD’s high-end marques are vying with BMW and Mercedes on technology and price [58] [59]. This means BMW must continue investing in innovation – from software features to battery tech – to entice Chinese consumers who have many alternatives. CEO Oliver Zipse has emphasized that BMW “can’t afford to make mistakes” in its electric transition in China, underscoring the strategic importance of getting EVs right for that market (a sentiment he expressed back in August as BMW geared up its EV push).
In the near term, all eyes will be on BMW’s Q3 2025 financial report due November 5. That report will provide more detailed numbers on how the Chinese slump and tariff expenses impacted the quarter, and management will likely face tough questions from analysts. Investors will be looking for any signs of stabilization in China – e.g. improvement in October sales or progress on clearing dealer inventories – and for updates on how order intake is holding up in other regions [60]. Any commentary on pricing strategy (have incentives been needed to support sales?) and on the EV sales mix in China could be telling, given the competitive pressures. Additionally, BMW’s response plan will be scrutinized. The firm has already implemented cost controls earlier in the year, and it may outline further efficiency or restructuring measures to protect margins. Its strong balance sheet and consistent profitability in recent years give it some cushion to absorb this year’s dip.
Despite the current gloom, BMW’s core business remains resilient in many markets. Year-to-date, sales in Europe and the U.S. have been growing at a healthy clip [61], and the brand’s appeal in the luxury segment remains robust. Moreover, the macro picture could turn more favorable: if China’s economy manages to pick up steam in 2026 (perhaps aided by government stimulus or simply an EV replacement cycle), BMW could see a rebound in that region after a year of retrenchment. Trade tensions, too, might ease – the tariff issue that hit 2025 should be resolved going forward if the EU-U.S. deal holds, removing that drag on earnings. There is also the wildcard of currency exchange rates (a weaker euro can boost European exporters like BMW), though predicting FX moves is tricky.
For now, BMW is in conservational mode, prioritizing profitability and shareholder returns through the storm. The company noted it will stick to its dividend policy and share buybacks, signaling confidence that cash flows will recover [62]. Some analysts even suggest that BMW’s warning could prod policymakers in Germany to pay closer attention to the auto sector’s challenges – from energy costs to competition – as it remains a vital industry. Indeed, the profit warning comes just as officials and industry leaders convene for an “Auto Summit” in Berlin to discuss support for the car industry [63]. How BMW adapts to the “new normal” in China and the evolving global trade environment will be crucial. But if it can leverage its strengths – a strong brand, engineering excellence, and a growing EV portfolio – analysts believe BMW can steer through this rough patch and regain momentum. As UBS’s Patrick Hummel and others maintain, the long-term thesis on BMW is intact, with the current stock price weakness reflecting short-term turbulence rather than a structural decline [64].
Sources:
- dpa-AFX via boerse.de/MarketScreener – UBS cuts BMW target to €95 but reiterates Buy [65]
- Süddeutsche Zeitung – BMW lowers annual forecast, cites US tariffs and China sales [66] [67]
- Reuters – BMW shares drop after profit forecast cut on tariffs, China weakness [68] [69]
- Reuters – Analysts highlight China as key to BMW’s outlook [70]
- Focus Online – “BMW-Aktie rauscht ab nach Gewinnwarnung” (Index Radar analysis) [71]
- TS2 Tech – Wall Street’s Wild 48 Hours (global market context) [72]
- TS2 Tech – China’s EV Revolution 2025 (China market trends) [73]
- BMWBlog – BMW issues profit warning on China market and tariff delays [74] [75]
References
1. www.reuters.com, 2. www.focus.de, 3. www.sueddeutsche.de, 4. www.bmwblog.com, 5. www.reuters.com, 6. www.bmwblog.com, 7. www.reuters.com, 8. www.reuters.com, 9. www.focus.de, 10. www.finanzen.net, 11. www.reuters.com, 12. de.marketscreener.com, 13. www.reuters.com, 14. www.reuters.com, 15. www.focus.de, 16. www.reuters.com, 17. www.sueddeutsche.de, 18. www.bmwblog.com, 19. ts2.tech, 20. www.reuters.com, 21. www.sueddeutsche.de, 22. www.sueddeutsche.de, 23. www.focus.de, 24. www.sueddeutsche.de, 25. www.bmwblog.com, 26. www.bmwblog.com, 27. ts2.tech, 28. www.bmwblog.com, 29. www.reuters.com, 30. www.reuters.com, 31. www.bmwblog.com, 32. www.reuters.com, 33. www.bmwblog.com, 34. www.bmwblog.com, 35. www.focus.de, 36. www.reuters.com, 37. www.focus.de, 38. www.finanzen.net, 39. de.marketscreener.com, 40. de.marketscreener.com, 41. www.reuters.com, 42. www.sueddeutsche.de, 43. ts2.tech, 44. ts2.tech, 45. www.wiwo.de, 46. www.focus.de, 47. de.marketscreener.com, 48. de.marketscreener.com, 49. de.marketscreener.com, 50. www.reuters.com, 51. www.reuters.com, 52. www.reuters.com, 53. www.reuters.com, 54. www.reuters.com, 55. www.focus.de, 56. de.marketscreener.com, 57. www.bmwblog.com, 58. ts2.tech, 59. ts2.tech, 60. www.reuters.com, 61. www.reuters.com, 62. www.bmwblog.com, 63. de.marketscreener.com, 64. de.marketscreener.com, 65. de.marketscreener.com, 66. www.sueddeutsche.de, 67. www.sueddeutsche.de, 68. www.reuters.com, 69. www.reuters.com, 70. www.reuters.com, 71. www.focus.de, 72. ts2.tech, 73. ts2.tech, 74. www.bmwblog.com, 75. www.bmwblog.com
