LIM Center, Aleje Jerozolimskie 65/79, 00-697 Warsaw, Poland
+48 (22) 364 58 00
ts@ts2.pl

Light Phone III vs Wisephone II vs Mudita Kompakt: The Ultimate Minimalist Phone Showdown

Light Phone III vs Wisephone II vs Mudita Kompakt: The Ultimate Minimalist Phone Showdown

0
Light Phone III vs Wisephone II vs Mudita Kompakt: The Ultimate Minimalist Phone Showdown

Minimalist phones – also known as “dumbphones” or digital detox phones – are making a comeback as people seek escape from constant notifications and screen-time overload. Unlike old flip phones, today’s minimalist handsets blend basic connectivity with just enough modern features, all while stripping away addictive apps and endless distractions. In this report, we compare three leading minimalist phones on the market – Light Phone III, Wisephone II, and Mudita Kompakt – covering everything from hardware specs and software features to pricing, design, user experience, and expert opinions. We’ll also look at upcoming minimalist devices like the Punkt. MC02 and others on the horizon.

Whether you’re a digital minimalist, a parent seeking a safer phone for your kid, or simply curious about the “anti-smartphone” movement, read on for a comprehensive breakdown of these devices – and find out which might suit your needs best.

Light Phone III – Premium Minimalism for Digital Detox

The Light Phone III is the latest model from Brooklyn-based Light, a company that helped kickstart the minimalist phone renaissance. Priced at $599 (pre-order) with a premium build, the Light Phone III aims to be a “smarter” minimalist phone without becoming a full-fledged smartphone theverge.com theverge.com. It’s designed as either a total smartphone replacement or a secondary “weekend” phone to disconnect after hours theverge.com. Here’s an overview of its key specs and features:

  • Build & Display: Blacked-out minimalist design with an aluminum chassis. It has a 3.92-inch AMOLED touchscreen (1080×1240) that displays a monochrome interface for minimal distraction theverge.com theverge.com. The OLED screen is sharp and much more responsive than the E-Ink display on the previous Light Phone, making typing and swiping smoother theverge.com theverge.com. (Light’s CEO noted the slow E-Ink was the #1 reason users gave up on the old model theverge.com.) The Phone III is chunky but compact – about 12 mm thick and 124 g – with a boxy shape that one reviewer said “feels a little like something a spy might carry” theverge.com. It’s rated IP54 (splash resistant) wired.com, with matte “mineral glass” on the screen for durability.
  • Hardware Specs: Under the hood it runs a modest Qualcomm SM4450 chipset (a midrange Snapdragon variant), with 6 GB RAM and 128 GB storage (non-expandable) theverge.com keyphone.tech. There’s finally a camera – a 50 MP rear camera and 8 MP front camera – a first for Light phones theverge.com keyphone.tech. Image quality is just okay (meant for quick snaps or scanning documents, not high-end photography theverge.com), but it “does take pictures!” which is an upgrade over having no camera at all theverge.com. The tiny 1,800 mAh battery sounds small, but with the phone’s limited functionality it lasts about 2–3 days per charge in real-world use theverge.com. Unusually, the battery is user-replaceable, which helps the device’s longevity theverge.com.
  • Connectivity: The Light Phone III is 5G-capable and supports 4G LTE on major carriers. There’s a single nano-SIM slot plus eSIM support for convenience wired.com. A big improvement over the previous model is that Light now offers one global version of the device, so it works worldwide without network compatibility issues (the Light Phone II had separate US/EU models) wired.com. It supports calls and texts (including group messaging), and can serve as a basic Wi-Fi hotspot keyphone.tech keyphone.tech. Bluetooth 5.0 is onboard for wireless audio keyphone.tech. The phone has modern additions like NFC, a fingerprint reader, and even a unique scroll wheel on the side – though as of launch, these are not fully utilized (NFC and fingerprint functions are not yet active, and the scroll wheel currently just toggles the flashlight and screen brightness) theverge.com theverge.com. Light says future software updates will enable things like tap-to-pay, secure fingerprint unlock, and more uses for that side wheel theverge.com theverge.com.
  • Light OS Software: Light Phone III runs Light OS, a custom distraction-free operating system. There is no app store, no web browser, no social media, no email – essentially none of the typical apps that occupy us on smartphones theverge.com. Instead, it comes with a set of built-in “Tools” (simple apps) focused on essentials and intentional use. Out of the box, tools include Phone (calls & SMS), Alarm, Calculator, Calendar, Contacts, Notes, Music player, Podcast player, a basic Maps/Directions tool, a simple camera app, a Voice Memos recorder, and a Timer wired.com wired.com. You won’t find WhatsApp, Instagram, YouTube, or any third-party apps on the device – and there’s no way to add them. In fact, adding even the built-in tools requires using an online dashboard from a computer to choose which tools to install on the phone theverge.com theverge.com. (This clunky setup process is deliberate, to discourage on-phone tinkering and keep the device itself simple.) The interface is text-based and gesture-driven – think old-school iPod simplicity with modern touches. Notably, the UI stays monochrome (black-and-white) almost everywhere, which Light says is to make it “unenticing” and reduce the dopamine pull of colorful apps theverge.com. One reviewer noted it’s actually jarring when you open the camera and suddenly see full color – a reminder that the OLED screen can show color, but Light works hard to hide it for everything except photos theverge.com.
  • User Experience: Using the Light Phone III means doing much less with your phone – by design. You can call, text, get directions, listen to podcasts or music, take the occasional photo, set an alarm, and not a lot more. This enforced simplicity is exactly what some users want. Experts have praised the Light Phone III’s intentional design: “The idea of the Light Phone is to turn ‘using your phone’ into a thing you do on purpose, not absentmindedly whenever your brain is unoccupied for three seconds,” writes The Verge, noting that using the Light Phone made them pick up their device far less often – “and that is a great thing.” theverge.com theverge.com. The hardware and UI are described as “lovely” and “intentionally unenticing”, successfully breaking the cycle of mindless scrolling theverge.com theverge.com. On the flip side, the minimalist approach has trade-offs in daily usability. There’s no on-screen keyboard autocorrect, no emoji, and texting is bare-bones. You can get turn-by-turn navigation, but the Maps tool is extremely simple (more like static directions lists and basic black-and-white maps) theverge.com. There’s no support for messaging apps like iMessage, WhatsApp or Signal – only plain SMS/MMS, which can be a deal-breaker for some (one reviewer quipped: “I just wish it had WhatsApp.” theverge.com). Another limitation is that some promised features weren’t ready at launch: the Light Phone III has a fingerprint sensor, NFC chip, and front camera capable of video calling, but these features remained inactive in early firmware theverge.com. Software updates are expected to unlock them, but as The Verge noted in mid-2025, the device still felt “unfinished” and early adopters might need patience theverge.com.
  • Target Audience: Light markets the Phone III to minimalists, creatives, and anyone craving a “digital detox.” It’s positioned as a device for people who “want much less screen time”, but still need basic connectivity theverge.com. Some users carry it as a secondary phone for weekends or evenings, swapping their SIM from a smartphone when they want to unplug wired.com. Interestingly, Light Phones have also been used in education – a few schools have given students Light Phones to avoid smartphone distractions on campus theverge.com. Because it lacks many features, it’s not ideal for anyone who needs frequent navigation, rideshare apps, banking apps, or group chats on their phone – it’s truly for those willing to sacrifice convenience for focus. Parents have shown interest in Light Phone for younger teens, though absence of parental tracking or messaging apps is a consideration.
  • Pricing & Availability: The Light Phone III is premium-priced for what it is. It launched at $599 for early adopters, and the company indicated the retail price would eventually rise to $699–$799 keyphone.tech keyphone.tech. Reviewers have noted the high cost – “practically smartphone-priced,” as The Verge put it theverge.com – especially given its limited capabilities. (Wired magazine joked that the $599 tag “made my dad spit out his coffee” wired.com.) For now it’s sold directly through Light’s website, shipping to customers in the US and internationally. Early pre-orders shipped in March 2025, with new orders expected to deliver by September 2025 thelightphone.com. There’s only one color (matte black), and the package includes the phone and basic accessories. Notably, Light does not require any subscription fees – once you buy the device, all the Light OS tools and updates are included for life, aside from whatever you pay your carrier for service.

Expert Verdict: The Light Phone III is often described as a beautifully made device that “comes tantalizingly close” to the ideal minimalist phone theverge.com. It earned positive reviews for its build quality and concept. The Verge gave it a 7/10, praising the “lovely hardware and software” and how it truly reduces screen-time theverge.com. WIRED rated it 8/10 and “WIRED Recommends,” calling it “the digital detox we need right now,” with the caveat that it’s “very expensive” and some features are missing or not fully baked yet wired.com. In short, Light Phone III is the choice for purists seeking a high-design, low-distraction phone – and who are willing to pay a premium for that experience.

Wisephone II – A Family-Friendly Simplified Smartphone

The Wisephone II takes a different approach to minimalism: it’s essentially a custom Android smartphone designed to be “the world’s healthiest smartphone,” balancing basic functionality with robust parental controls and curated app access whatifididnt.com. Made by Texas-based startup Techless, the Wisephone looks like a regular modern phone, but its software (WiseOS) strips away the usual culprits of screen addiction. Launched in mid-2024, the Wisephone 2 is primarily sold in the United States, targeting families, teens, and digital minimalists who still need certain apps (like maps or banking) but in a locked-down environment whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Hardware & Design: Interestingly, the Wisephone II isn’t custom hardware – it’s built on a Samsung Galaxy A-series device (the company uses a Samsung Galaxy A15 as the base) whatifididnt.com. That means it has a fairly standard mid-range smartphone design: a candybar form factor with a large color touchscreen. The Wisephone 2 has a 6.5-inch class display (Samsung’s LCD, 60Hz), and a slim body (~8.4 mm thick) whatifididnt.com. Its dimensions (160.1 × 76.8 mm) and ~6.5 oz weight make it significantly larger and heavier than the Light or Mudita phones whatifididnt.com. It looks and feels like any modern Android phone – which can be a plus for usability (easy to hold, big screen for typing), though one user did complain “the phone is HUGE… bigger than an iPhone… I hope a future iteration finds a smaller version.” reddit.com The build is likely a plastic frame and back (typical of Samsung’s A-series), with a glass front. There’s a nice bonus that many new phones lack: a 3.5mm headphone jack for audio whatifididnt.com. Overall, if you handed someone a Wisephone with the screen off, they might not guess it’s a “dumbphone” – the minimalism is all in the software.
  • Specs: Since it’s basically a Samsung under the hood, the Wisephone II has solid mid-tier specs. It runs on a Qualcomm or Samsung Exynos midrange CPU (exact chip not public, but performance is described as fast and “snappy”). It comes with 6 GB RAM and 128 GB internal storage, plus it supports microSD cards for expansion – a feature power users will appreciate whatifididnt.com. For photography, it surprisingly packs a 50 MP rear camera (leveraging the Samsung hardware) which can take decent photos whatifididnt.com. This high-resolution camera is unusual for a minimalist phone – far higher than Mudita’s 8 MP camera and even a bit above Light Phone’s – and reviewers note it as a perk for capturing memories without a full smartphone whatifididnt.com. There’s also a front selfie camera (spec not advertised, likely around 8 MP). Battery capacity isn’t explicitly listed, but Samsung A-series devices typically have around a 5,000 mAh battery, which, combined with the toned-down software, yields excellent battery life. (Techless advertises “great battery life,” and users report it easily lasts a full day or more of use wisephone.com.) The phone charges via USB-C and does not support wireless charging (not mentioned, so presumably no).
  • WiseOS Software & App Support: What truly defines Wisephone II is WiseOS, a custom Android-based operating system built by Techless. Visually, the interface is extremely minimal – no app icons, no colorful wallpapers. The home screen is just simple text menus on a plain background whatifididnt.com. As Techless puts it, “Icons and colors are addictive… text doesn’t have this effect,” so the phone’s UI is intentionally “simple and boring, in a good way” whatifididnt.com catalannews.com. Out of the box (with no subscription), WiseOS offers only the bare essentials: Phone (calls), Messages (SMS), and Camera whatifididnt.com. This default “Basic Experience” essentially turns the device into a high-end “dumbphone” – you can call and text reliably (something many basic flip phones ironically struggle with reddit.com), but nothing else distracts you whatifididnt.com. However, most users will opt for the paid subscription to unlock more features and apps (more on pricing below). With the subscription, you get the “Essential Tools”: core apps like Music player, Calendar, Calculator, Notes, Voice Recorder, Alarm, and Two-Factor Authenticator whatifididnt.com. You also gain access to the Tool Drawer, which is Wisephone’s version of an app store – a curated selection of 300+ third-party apps that have been vetted by Techless for “healthy” usage whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. Importantly, Wisephone allows many popular apps that Light Phone and Mudita do not: for example, you can install WhatsApp, Signal, Slack, Google Maps (Waze), Uber, Lyft, Spotify, banking apps, and more via the Tool Drawer whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. What you won’t find are apps deemed addictive or problematic – no social media, no web browsers, no YouTube/Netflix, no games, no app store (the Tool Drawer replaces Play Store) whatifididnt.com. Essentially, WiseOS tries to include useful apps (messaging, navigation, finance, productivity) while excluding the endless-scroll apps and entertainment that cause distraction whatifididnt.com. Techless evaluates apps against a proprietary “Healthy Tech Index” (10 criteria analyzing an app’s effects on well-being, privacy, etc.) to decide what’s allowed whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. If your favorite app isn’t in the store, you can even request it be added – each request is manually reviewed whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. This approach has led to even some niche apps (from guitar tuners to local bank apps) being added over time whatifididnt.com. The result is that a fully-unlocked Wisephone can function much like a limited Android smartphone: you could use WhatsApp for messaging, listen to podcasts, check email via a web-less email app (though email might not be available – Techless explicitly blocks email apps by default as they can also be distracting whatifididnt.com), get directions, and perform everyday tasks – all in a tightly controlled, family-safe environment. WiseOS also includes family/parental features like Life360 (location tracking for family members) and an upcoming Family Portal that lets a parent or spouse monitor calls, texts, and location history if desired whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. There’s even a built-in pornography filter and block on explicit content, aligning with Techless’s mission to promote healthy tech use (the founders cite concerns like how smartphones facilitate easy access to harmful content) thephoenixspirit.com whatifididnt.com.
  • Subscription Model: Unlike Light or Mudita, Techless monetizes Wisephone through a monthly subscription for the full experience. The device itself costs $399 (base price) whatifididnt.com. Without a subscription, as noted, it’s call-and-text only. To unlock the Essential Tools and Tool Drawer (third-party apps), users pay $14.99/month whatifididnt.com. The subscription also covers ongoing software updates, security, and cloud management – Techless describes it as funding “a robust safety framework” that keeps the phone locked down and secure whatifididnt.com. You can choose between two software modes: Essential Mode (only core tools + a handful of pre-selected apps, but no manual app installs – intended for kids or the easily distracted) and Expanded Mode (full access to install any allowed app) whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. Both modes require the subscription; they’re just different levels of restriction. The need to pay a monthly fee has drawn some criticism – as one commenter put it, “this is a Samsung phone with Android, and you’re paying $15/month for Techless to basically manage your phone as if it’s been issued by your boss” reddit.com. However, others (including users on the r/dumbphones forum) argue that the service is worth it for those who want an enforced distraction-free life and don’t mind outsourcing the device management reddit.com reddit.com. It essentially functions like a mobile device management (MDM) solution on a personal phone – providing governance and filtering that tech-savvy users could maybe do themselves with free tools, but many prefer not to tinker with.
  • User Experience: For day-to-day use, the Wisephone 2 is meant to feel simpler than a normal smartphone, but more capable than a flip phone. Because it can run many common apps (in a controlled way), it avoids some of the frustrations that pure minimalist devices have. For example, texting is fully supported (no iMessage, but SMS/MMS work reliably, and you can even use WhatsApp if subscribed). One early adopter who had used basic flip phones said: “I can send a * text message. It’s been years since I’ve been able to do this [reliably]. I’m so pleased.” reddit.com reddit.com. Basic functions like calling and GPS are solid – the Wisephone can “consistently make phone calls, send texts, and has clear GPS” in tests, outperforming many basic keypad phones in those areas restoredtoland.com. The interface’s lack of icons or animations means navigation is just scrolling through lists of text (which some might find too barren, but others appreciate for its clarity). If you have the expanded mode, you might be scrolling through a textual list of all your allowed apps in the “Tool Drawer” – it’s not flashy, but it’s functional. The large touchscreen makes things like typing and reading maps far easier than on an E-Ink device like Mudita. For demographics: Techless explicitly markets to families. The Wisephone II is pitched as “the perfect first phone for kids/teens” – giving them necessary connectivity and useful apps for school (maps, authenticator, calendar), without the social media, games, and web browser that parents worry about whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. It also appeals to parents themselves and busy adults who want a calmer phone – Techless’ site mentions moms who want to stay reachable but not sucked into Instagram, etc. whatifididnt.com. And for elderly users, the large display and simplified menu can be easier to use than both tiny flip phones and feature-cluttered smartphones whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. (The Essential Mode caters to this by keeping only basic tools visible.) A potential downside is reliance on Techless’s ecosystem: the phone needs the subscription and their server support for the curated app installs and possibly for device setup/updates. This raises the concern that if Techless ever shuts down, the device could lose functionality beyond calls/texts reddit.com. Enthusiasts have noted you could bypass WiseOS entirely by installing standard Android on the hardware, but that would defeat the purpose reddit.com.
  • Privacy and Security: The Wisephone’s focus is more on digital well-being than hardcore privacy or anonymity. It does not run Google services by default (since there’s no Play Store), which is a plus for privacy. But it can install many third-party apps that do phone-home (e.g. banking apps, Uber, etc.), so it’s not a completely de-Googled environment like Mudita or Punkt’s phones. Techless positions their curation as partly about privacy – they claim to vet apps’ privacy policies and data practices whatifididnt.com – and the subscription supports “advanced safety framework” features that likely include malware blocking and system-level protections whatifididnt.com. There is no mention of encryption beyond standard Android features, and since apps like WhatsApp/Signal are allowed, users can have secure messaging if they choose. One strong privacy feature is the ability to block unknown callers/messages – you can set the phone so that only saved contacts can reach you, eliminating spam calls and texts dumbwireless.com. Overall, WiseOS tries to keep the user’s digital life secure and filtered (especially for kids), but if one is seeking anonymity from Big Tech, other devices (like Mudita or Punkt) go further by being fully Google-free and including VPNs.
  • Pricing & Plans: Device cost: $399 (often with promo codes available). Subscription: $14.99/month (month-to-month) for the full feature set whatifididnt.com. Techless also sells its own cellular plans (running on major networks) that bundle the subscription. For example, a “Minimal” plan with 1 GB data + unlimited talk/text + subscription is $24.99/month, and a “Pro” plan with 50 GB data + hotspot is $69.99/month whatifididnt.com. However, you can use the Wisephone with any carrier – it’s fully unlocked. Currently it only ships to U.S. addresses (with Canada and Europe expansion planned in late 2025) whatifididnt.com. The phone comes with a 14-day return policy (if in pristine condition) whatifididnt.com, so buyers can try it and send back if it’s not a fit. There’s a growing second-hand market as well, since some users decide the subscription model isn’t for them.
  • Sustainability: Being based on Samsung hardware, the Wisephone benefits from a robust, energy-efficient design, but there’s no specific mention of eco-friendly materials or ethical sourcing. It’s not as easily user-serviceable as the Light Phone (no simple way to replace the battery yourself). Techless’s model does encourage long-term use of the same device through software updates – rather than annual hardware upgrades – which has some sustainability merit. Still, it’s not focused on the ethical manufacturing angle (unlike, say, Fairphone, which is a different niche).

Expert and User Opinions: The Wisephone II has received a mix of praise and skepticism. Many digital wellness advocates appreciate its balanced approach. The Phoenix Spirit, a lifestyle publication, found it “strikes the right balance between tech and no tech,” offering just the simple capabilities needed thephoenixspirit.com. Users on Reddit who have lived without smartphones for years said Wisephone was “fantastic – I love it,” because it let them text and use basic maps/music again without opening the floodgates to distraction reddit.com reddit.com. On the other hand, some tech reviewers note that you are essentially paying a lot for restrictions you could impose on a normal phone for free. The $15 monthly fee is controversial – one power-user called it reasonable for the service, while another said they felt “hoodwinked” when they realized it’s just a managed Android with a fee reddit.com reddit.com. In sum, Wisephone II is ideal if you want an iPhone/Android-like device minus the “bad” apps and are willing to subscribe for that peace of mind. It’s particularly compelling for parents who want to give a teenager a phone that’s almost impossible to misuse for social media or inappropriate content. But if you’re an individual simply looking to unplug, the recurring cost and the fact that it’s basically a repurposed Samsung might give you pause.

Mudita Kompakt – Mindful Phone with E-Ink Serenity

Poland-based Mudita offers a different flavor of minimalist phone with its new Mudita Kompakt. Launched in 2025 after a successful crowdfunding campaign, the Kompakt is a 4.3-inch E-Ink phone focused on mindfulness, privacy, and “digital detox when you need it.” mudita.com Mudita’s first phone (the Mudita Pure) was an ultra-basic device; the Kompakt builds on that concept with more features and modern connectivity, while still using an E Ink electronic paper display for a gentler, eye-friendly experience techaeris.com. Think of Mudita Kompakt as the zen option: it won’t win any spec wars, but it promises a calm, distraction-free mobile life.

  • Design & Hardware: The Mudita Kompakt has a distinctive rounded design reminiscent of older smartphones like the Palm Pre or iPhone 3G techaeris.com. It’s compact but slightly stubby – 128 × 70 × 12.6 mm in size and 164 g in weight techaeris.com. The front is almost all screen (with thick bezels, since E-Ink panels usually need borders), and the back is a soft-touch polycarbonate with a matte finish and internal metal frame for rigidity techaeris.com. It fits nicely in one hand, and reviewers note it has a very comfortable, grippy feel – if a bit of a fingerprint magnet on the soft back techaeris.com. The Kompakt is built to be durable: the display is covered by hard coated glass (8H hardness) techaeris.com, and the body is water-resistant to IP54 (splashes/dust) like the Light Phone techaeris.com. Mudita even includes thoughtful extras like a physical slider switch for “Offline Mode”, which instantly hardware-disconnects the cellular modem and microphones (and also disables camera, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth via software) for true privacy or airplane use store.mudita.com techaeris.com. This is similar to the “kill switch” idea on some privacy-focused phones. Another privacy nod: the Kompakt has very low SAR (radiation) emissions by design (a philosophy Mudita carried from its first phone, aiming to minimize electromagnetic exposure). In the box, Mudita includes a few mindful touches: you get a canvas carry pouch and even “Meditation Cards” with the phone techaeris.com, highlighting its wellness orientation.
  • E-Ink Display: The standout feature is the 4.3″ E-Ink Carta display (800×480 resolution) store.mudita.com. Unlike the OLED or LCD screens on Light and Wisephone, this is a monochrome e-paper display – similar to a Kindle e-reader screen. It doesn’t emit harsh light or color; it looks like printed text on paper. The advantages are zero blue light (easier on the eyes and sleep cycles), perfect sunlight readability (great for outdoor use), and extreme power efficiency when displaying static content store.mudita.com. Mudita touts up to 5–6 days of battery life on a charge thanks in part to the E-Ink’s frugality store.mudita.com. The downsides: E-Ink refreshes slower than normal screens, so animations or fast scrolling can be janky. However, the Kompakt’s E-Ink is much faster than older ones – reviews note that it’s surprisingly smooth for texting and navigation (Mudita likely uses partial refresh and a decent refresh rate to minimize lag). It won’t handle video or complex animations, but it’s sufficient for the phone’s simple UI and even for reading long texts or e-books (yes, it includes a basic e-book reader app) dumbwireless.com. The display is also not touch-responsive like an OLED; actually, it is a touchscreen (capacitive) – you can tap and swipe – but with some latency. The interface design smartly avoids things that need rapid swipes. Overall, if you crave a screen that doesn’t seduce you into staring at it, Kompakt’s E-Ink delivers a “paper-like reading experience” that several reviewers loved dumbwireless.com techaeris.com.
  • Specs & Performance: Under the hood, the Mudita Kompakt runs on a modest MediaTek MT6761V quad-core processor (known as the Helio A22, a low-end chipset) store.mudita.com. It has 3 GB of RAM and 32 GB storage, plus a microSD slot (shared with a second SIM slot) for expansion techaeris.com techaeris.com. These specs are quite low by smartphone standards, but adequate for the lightweight MuditaOS and E-Ink usage. In practice, the performance is sufficient – one review gave it 8.5/10 for performance, noting that aside from the inherent E-Ink slowness for some actions, the phone ran stable and smooth for its intended tasks techaeris.com techaeris.com. Connectivity-wise, Kompakt isn’t about cutting-edge speeds: it supports up to 4G LTE (no 5G, which helps battery life). It has Wi-Fi 5 and Bluetooth 5.0 for local connections techaeris.com. Dual SIM support is there (one nano-SIM + one hybrid slot that can be SIM2 or microSD), and it even supports eSIM as an alternative to a second SIM card techaeris.com. There’s an NFC chip as well techaeris.com, though currently it’s used mainly for simple tasks (it could potentially be used for contactless payments or transferring contacts in the future). For navigation, the phone includes a GPS receiver (with Glonass and Galileo support) so it can do location and mapping offline techaeris.com. Battery is a strong suit: a 3,300 mAh Li-Polymer battery combined with E-Ink yields excellent longevity. Mudita claims up to 6 days standby androidguys.com; real-world use can be several days per charge depending on usage. Charging is via USB-C (up to 10W) and it even supports basic wireless charging (Qi at 2.5W) – a nice touch for convenience techaeris.com techaeris.com.
  • Camera: Unlike Mudita’s first phone which had no camera, the Kompakt does include a simple 8 MP rear camera with LED flash techaeris.com. There is no front-facing camera at all – reinforcing that this isn’t for video calls or selfies. The camera quality is, by modern standards, very basic. Reviewers note it’s “not great,” with images on par with an old smartphone – but in Mudita’s philosophy, that’s intentional: the camera is there for “digitizing documents or capturing memories” in a pinch, not for endless photography sessions store.mudita.com techaeris.com. The E-Ink screen also displays photos in grayscale only, which diminishes any urge to use the phone as a media device. If high-quality photography matters to you, this phone isn’t it – but if you just need to scan a receipt or snap a quick memory, it suffices (and you won’t be tempted to spend an hour editing it on the device).
  • Mudita OS (Kompakt) & Features: Mudita Kompakt runs MuditaOS “K”, a custom operating system built on open-source AOSP (Android Open Source Project) but completely de-Googled techaeris.com. This is a major shift from Mudita’s first device, which ran a custom OS not based on Android (and had many software issues). By using AOSP, Mudita could implement more features reliably while keeping the experience minimalist. The interface is clean, text-based and supports multiple languages (English, Polish, German, French, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Dutch, etc.) dumbwireless.com. Essential tools come pre-installed, similar to Light Phone’s approach but with a few extras. According to Mudita’s materials, features include: Calls and SMS messaging, Contacts, Offline Maps & Navigation (using OpenStreetMap data stored on the device, so you don’t need internet for GPS) store.mudita.com, Music player (for MP3s and audio files you can load), Notes, Calendar, Alarm/Clock, Voice Recorder, Weather updates, Calculator, and even some wellness extras like a Meditation timer app and a simple Chess game for mindful breaks dumbwireless.com dumbwireless.com. There’s also an E-book reader (E-Ink is perfect for reading long texts), and a File Manager for managing files. Notably, Mudita includes a “Mudita Center” desktop app that you can use on your computer to manage the phone – transfer music, import contacts, update firmware, and (newly) to sideload apps if you really want dumbwireless.com dumbwireless.com. Yes, unlike Light Phone, the Kompakt can install third-party Android apps – but there’s no on-device app store. You would download an APK on your PC and use Mudita Center to load it onto the phone dumbwireless.com. This process is technical enough that only determined users will do it, and many Android apps won’t work well on an E-Ink screen or without Google services. Still, it provides a measure of openness for those who truly need an app like WhatsApp or an authenticator – some users have reported successfully sideloading WhatsApp, Signal, authenticator apps, etc., though of course in grayscale and without push notifications (since no Google Cloud Messaging) dumbwireless.com techaeris.com. By default, MuditaOS does not include any addictive apps or a browser – you’d have to deliberately add those, which most Kompakt users won’t. The interface is very straightforward: think old Nokia phone menu, but on a touch E-Ink. One retailer described it as “fully custom OS with continuous OTA updates… simple and focused” dumbwireless.com dumbwireless.com. The home shows a few menu items (Phone, Messages, etc.), and you navigate with taps or the side button. The Offline Mode switch (the physical toggle) instantly cuts connectivity for true peace – essentially an ultra Airplane Mode that ensures nothing (not even system processes) is transmitting store.mudita.com. This is great for meditation sessions or just unplugging without turning off the device. Another interesting feature: blocking unknown numbers – Kompakt lets you allow calls/texts only from contacts, which means spam or unknown numbers won’t disturb you dumbwireless.com. This ties into its “enjoy peace and quiet” ethos.
  • User Experience: Using Mudita Kompakt is described as a very intentional, slower-paced experience. As one reviewer put it, “The Mudita Kompakt does what it does very well… but this phone isn’t for everyone.” techaeris.com It excels at freeing you from the smartphone grind – there’s no endless feed to check, and even if you get tempted, the grayscale slow screen quickly reminds you it’s not meant for that. For example, you can technically read news via the browser if you sideload one, but doing so on E-Ink is tedious. Instead, you’re more likely to use the phone for a quick call, a text exchange, listening to some MP3 music, or looking up a saved map route. In daily life, Kompakt is great for: outdoor use (screen clear in sunlight), keeping phone use minimal during family time or work, and focusing on tasks (the phone won’t be buzzing with social media). It’s also very eye-friendly – people sensitive to backlit screens love that E-Ink has no glare or blue light store.mudita.com. Battery life means you don’t worry about charging daily – it can last several days of light use, so you might charge only twice a week, reducing “battery anxiety.” For different demographics: Mudita explicitly mentions it can be a “perfect companion” secondary phone – for when you want to disconnect from your main smartphone for a while store.mudita.com. It’s also pitched to health-conscious users (to reduce eye strain and screen addiction), and privacy-conscious folks (no big tech tracking, and one can physically disconnect radios) store.mudita.com store.mudita.com. Parents might consider it for kids, since it has no social apps – though a child may find it too limiting (and there’s no easy family tracking feature like Wisephone). For older users, the high-contrast e-paper and simple UI could be a plus (easy to read text), but the responsiveness is slower than a normal phone, which could frustrate some. One tech reviewer admitted “I couldn’t do it” as a full replacement because they were too used to smartphone conveniences, but also said “for those it is for, it’s a pretty outstanding choice.” techaeris.com techaeris.com In other words, if you come in with the right expectations – essentially treating it like a phone that liberates you from constant connectivity – you may love the peace it provides. If you expect it to behave like an Android phone, you’ll be frustrated.
  • Privacy & Ethics: Mudita places a high value on privacy and ethical tech. The Kompakt has no ads, no trackers, no data mining – your data stays on the device store.mudita.com. Being de-Googled, it won’t ping Google or Facebook in the background. The Offline hardware switch is a rare feature that ensures nothing can secretly listen or transmit. They also stress low SAR emissions, meaning the phone is engineered to reduce radiation (for those concerned about the health aspect of carrying a phone). On sustainability, Mudita is a smaller company and doesn’t make bold claims about sourcing, but the phone’s longevity and repairability are considered. It uses standard components and Mudita has committed to providing long-term software updates (they even open-sourced parts of MuditaOS for community contributions). The battery, while not user-swappable in daily use, could presumably be serviced by Mudita if needed. Packaging is eco-friendly and the inclusion of a durable canvas bag hints at reducing plastic waste. Mudita’s ethos is generally about “mindful manufacturing” – they likely produce in smaller batches and focus on quality over quantity. (The phones are assembled in Europe and Asia, with design in Poland.)
  • Pricing & Availability: The Mudita Kompakt retails for $439 (in the US) or about €420 in Europe store.mudita.com. It’s sold through Mudita’s online store and a few specialty retailers (like dumbwireless.com in the US). Unlike Wisephone, no subscription or service fees are required – once you buy it, all features are available. Mudita offers a 14-day trial/return policy – you can return the Kompakt within 14 days if it’s not for you store.mudita.com (something Light Phone does not offer audiosciencereview.com). The phone comes in one variant but you must choose a regional version for proper LTE bands – there’s a North American model and an EU/rest-of-world model (Mudita’s site will prompt your region) dumbwireless.com. The company ships to most countries worldwide (US, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, etc. are supported) store.mudita.com. Given it’s a niche product, production is sometimes limited; early backers on Kickstarter got their units in early 2025, and as of mid-2025 it’s generally in stock with a week’s delivery in major regions store.mudita.com.

Expert Verdict: The Mudita Kompakt has impressed reviewers within its niche. Tech website Techaeris gave it a 9/10 score overall, praising its build quality, “excellent battery life,” and the stress-free experience it provides techaeris.com techaeris.com. They highlighted how it “removes you from smartphone chains” effectively techaeris.com. Pros listed include the comfortable design, “nice e-ink display that looks good in all lighting,” and even the ability to sideload apps if truly needed techaeris.com techaeris.com. The cons were the mediocre speaker and camera, which ironically serve the philosophy by not encouraging overuse techaeris.com. Another reviewer noted it’s “truly the device for those who want to be disconnected” techaeris.com. Common to all reviews is the admission that Kompakt is not for everyone – but for a minimalist who prioritizes mindfulness, privacy, and simplicity, it may be the “minimalist’s dream phone” goodereader.com. It stands out by virtue of that E-Ink display – offering a fundamentally different way to interact with a phone (more calm, less stimulus) – which could be its biggest selling point for the right user.

Comparing the Contenders: Which Minimalist Phone Fits You?

Each of these three phones embodies a distinct philosophy within the minimalist phone movement. Here’s a side-by-side look at how Light Phone III, Wisephone II, and Mudita Kompakt differ in key areas:

  • Hardware & Design: Light Phone III is the smallest and most premium-built – a compact matte-black brick with an aluminum frame and OLED screen. It feels like a tiny high-end gadget, easily pocketable, with a quirky scroll wheel and minimalist aesthetic theverge.com theverge.com. Wisephone II looks like a regular modern smartphone (because it is one under the hood) – large 6.5″ display, thin profile, likely a plastic build; not visually “minimalist” on the outside, which can be an advantage for usability (big screen, familiar form) but means it won’t stand out as a specialty device. Mudita Kompakt sits in between: smaller than Wisephone but chunkier than Light, with a unique soft-touch design and E-Ink screen. It’s arguably the most ergonomic and comfortable to hold, and its retro-modern look will appeal to those who like “different” gadgets. All three are sturdy: Light and Mudita have IP54 resistance and durable materials, Wisephone (Samsung base) is robust but not water-rated. Only Mudita and Punkt’s phones include headphone jacks among minimalist devices whatifididnt.com techaeris.com, so audiophiles or those with wired headphones might favor Mudita (Light relies on Bluetooth or USB-C audio, Wisephone has a jack).
  • Display Experience: This is a major differentiator. Light Phone III and Wisephone II use OLED/LCD screens that are bright and colorful (Light intentionally uses monochrome UI, but the screen itself is high-res and could do color) theverge.com. Light’s small AMOLED is sharp but only black-and-white in interface, which many say makes it easier on the eyes than typical smartphones theverge.com. Wisephone’s large LCD is likely full-color but the WiseOS interface uses a plain black-and-white theme to keep it “boring” whatifididnt.com. Still, when using allowed apps like Maps or WhatsApp on Wisephone, you’ll see full colors and graphics – so the temptation of a “normal” smartphone display is present, albeit without the worst apps. Mudita Kompakt’s E-Ink is in a category of its own: completely grayscale, no backlight glare (it might have a front-light for night use, not mentioned but likely), and slow refresh. It’s the best for reading and avoiding eye strain store.mudita.com, but worst for any dynamic content. If you loathe glowing screens, Mudita wins; if you can’t stand ghosting or low video capability, stick to Light or Wisephone.
  • Software Philosophy: Here the choice is clear: Light Phone III = Extreme minimalism. No third-party apps, just a fixed set of tools intended to reduce your phone usage to the bare essentials theverge.com. It’s for users who are ready to surrender almost all “smart” features. Wisephone II = Moderation and control. It allows a controlled selection of apps that many people need daily (messaging, maps, banking) but bans the “toxic” apps and web browsing whatifididnt.com whatifididnt.com. It’s like a highly filtered smartphone – good for someone who wants fewer distractions but can’t ditch certain conveniences. Mudita Kompakt = Mindful simplicity with open possibilities. Out of the box it has only basic tools (like Light), but if a user is tech-savvy they can sideload an app or two for specific needs dumbwireless.com dumbwireless.com. Its core experience is more akin to a feature phone (calls, SMS, music, offline nav) with a wellness twist (meditation timer, etc.), firmly targeting those who want to disconnect yet stay reachable store.mudita.com. Additionally, privacy is a sliding scale: Mudita probably leads (no big tech services at all, open-source core, hardware kill-switch) store.mudita.com, Light Phone also is very private (no apps, no trackers – but its OS is proprietary), and Wisephone is private from a content perspective (no social media) but does allow many apps that could share data, plus it relies on Techless’s cloud for management. If avoiding Google/Apple is a priority, note that Light and Mudita operate independently of Google/Apple ecosystems, whereas Wisephone’s allowed app list does include some Google services (like Google Maps, Google Drive) whatifididnt.com which likely require a Google account.
  • Features & Apps: Calling and Texting: All three handle basic telephony and messaging. Wisephone and Mudita support group SMS and picture messages; Light Phone can do SMS/MMS as well (though group texting on Light was a bit clunky in earlier models, it’s presumably improved). Camera: Wisephone has by far the best camera (50 MP, plus presumably modern sensor quality) whatifididnt.com. Light’s 50 MP is okay but the software is basic so results are modest theverge.com. Mudita’s 8 MP is purely utilitarian techaeris.com. If taking photos is something you care about at all, Wisephone will deliver the best shots (and you could actually share them via WhatsApp or email if needed). Navigation: Mudita and Wisephone both have navigation: Mudita with offline maps (no live traffic, just basic directions) theverge.com, Wisephone with full Google Maps or Waze if you allow it whatifididnt.com (which means real-time directions, search, etc.). Light Phone’s “Directions” tool works but is very simple – more like printing out MapQuest directions in advance theverge.com. So for someone who drives a lot or needs robust GPS, Wisephone provides the richest navigation experience, Mudita gives you a privacy-friendly but bare-bones offline map, and Light’s is minimalist and might not satisfy for complex travel. Music/Audio: All three can play music: Light has a music player (no streaming though, you load songs or podcasts via the dashboard) theverge.com, Mudita supports MP3 playback and even has a podcast downloader, etc., plus the headphone jack is a bonus techaeris.com. Wisephone with subscription can run Spotify or other streaming apps whatifididnt.com – a big plus if you want Spotify playlists on a distraction-free phone (neither Light nor Mudita can do Spotify natively, since they have no official app store). Internet and Email: Only Wisephone (with subscription) allows email apps and some internet-dependent apps (it blocks browsers but one could use an email client or even Microsoft Teams, etc.) whatifididnt.com. Light and Mudita deliberately have no email or browser. So for someone who truly needs email on their phone for work, Wisephone is the viable minimalist choice (or the upcoming Punkt smartphone, discussed below). Extra Tools: Light and Mudita include a few thoughtful extras – e.g., Light has a simple Notes app and a Calculator wired.com, Mudita has a Notes, Calculator, Voice recorder, and even Chess and an e-book reader dumbwireless.com. Wisephone’s tools depend on subscription: without it, you don’t even have a calculator; with it, you do (and even more via apps). So, out of the box, Light/Mudita are more functional. But fully enabled, Wisephone surpasses them in versatility due to that curated app ecosystem.
  • Ease of Use: Wisephone II is arguably the easiest transition for a smartphone user. Its large screen, familiar Android underpinnings, and ability to install common apps mean you don’t have to change your habits as much – you still use a touchscreen keyboard, you still have WhatsApp for group chats, just without the worst temptations. The trade-off is you must trust Techless to “police” your phone usage. Light Phone III has a learning curve (its interface is unique and very pared-down, and you have to use a web dashboard for setup) theverge.com. But once set up, it’s very straightforward – actually fewer functions means fewer things to learn. It’s quite intuitive for calling and texting, just don’t expect any hidden tricks; in fact some habits (like copy-paste text or using voice dictation) might not be available. Mudita Kompakt’s user experience is a bit different due to E-Ink. Simple tasks like scrolling through contacts or typing a message work fine, but require a slightly slower, patient approach. For instance, the keyboard on E-Ink might have a tiny lag; you probably won’t type out long paragraphs of text as you might on Wisephone. On the plus side, Mudita has physical volume and offline switches which can simplify common actions. Each phone can serve older users, but Wisephone’s larger text (adjustable via accessibility perhaps) and straightforward Android base might be easiest for seniors. Mudita’s reflective screen could be great for those with eye issues, and its interface is arguably as simple as old feature phones, which older folks might find comforting (no flashy icons, just list menus).
  • Price & Ongoing Costs: The financial aspect is crucial:
    • Light Phone III: ~$599 now ($799 later) keyphone.tech keyphone.tech. No extra fees beyond your carrier plan. It’s expensive upfront but then it’s yours to use freely.
    • Wisephone II: $399 upfront whatifididnt.com, plus $15/month for the full experience whatifididnt.com. Over one year that’s ~$579 total, over two years ~$759, making it actually potentially more costly than the Light Phone. If you forego the subscription, you have a $399 dumbphone that only calls/texts – not a great value. So Wisephone really assumes you’ll pay continuously. (They do bundle the sub with their own plans as noted, which can be convenient but their plans are a bit pricey for the data offered whatifididnt.com.) This model is more akin to how software or services are sold, and it ensures Techless can support the platform.
    • Mudita Kompakt: $439 one-time store.mudita.com. No subscriptions. It sits in the middle for upfront cost and then it’s just your SIM plan. Given its build and feature set, that price feels more palatable than Light’s to many – you pay less than a mid-range smartphone price and get a specialized device. Mudita also has that 14-day money-back guarantee youtube.com which mitigates risk.
    • Value: If you consider a 2-year span: Light Phone will cost you $600–700 once, Mudita $439, Wisephone about $400 + $360 (sub) = $760. So Mudita is the budget-friendly choice long-term. Light is priciest initially, Wisephone ends up priciest with subscriptions. This might factor into a family decision – e.g., equipping a teenager with a Wisephone locks in a monthly cost versus a Light or Mudita which are paid for.
  • Target Users Summary:
    • Light Phone III – Best for digital detox purists and style-conscious minimalists. If you want absolutely no internet temptations and are attracted by a beautifully designed mini-phone that intentionally does less, Light is for you. It’s also a statement device (many users love the ethos and community around it). However, you need to be comfortable with its limitations and its high price.
    • Wisephone II – Best for families, tech addicts in recovery, and those seeking a “walled garden” smartphone. If you or your child need some apps (messaging, maps) but want them without the rabbit holes of social media and web, Wisephone offers that middle ground. It’s most like a “controlled smartphone” experience. You do need to buy into the subscription and trust the company’s curation. It’s less about aesthetics or mindfulness and more about practical restriction and safety.
    • Mudita Kompakt – Best for privacy enthusiasts, wellness-focused users, and the screen-weary. If you value eye comfort, long battery life, and privacy and don’t mind a slower pace, Mudita is ideal. It appeals to those who might enjoy reading on e-paper, who perhaps want a secondary phone for retreats/vacations, or anyone with sensitivity to constant screen glare. It’s also quite usable as a daily driver for someone whose digital needs genuinely are just calls, texting, music, and occasional navigation. The learning curve is small, but the paradigm shift (no instant info, everything a bit slower) is something to adapt to.

In the end, “going dumb” doesn’t mean going backward,” as one minimalist phone roundup put it – it’s about choosing the right balance of connectivity and peace keyphone.tech. Light Phone III represents one end of that spectrum (most extreme simplicity), Wisephone II the other end (almost a normal phone but heavily managed), and Mudita Kompakt somewhere in the middle with a tilt toward wellness. Your choice might depend on questions like: Do I need WhatsApp or Maps regularly? (If yes, Light won’t cut it – consider Wisephone, or Mudita with some effort), Do I crave zero distractions, full stop? (Light or Mudita shine there), Am I okay paying a subscription for convenience? (Wisephone’s model), Do I prefer a phone that doesn’t even feel like a screen? (Mudita’s e-ink).

Upcoming and Rumored Minimalist Phones

The minimalist and “digital detox” phone space is evolving rapidly. In the next year or two, several new devices and concepts are slated to launch, each with its own twist on the minimalist ethos. Here are a few to watch, including the much-anticipated Punkt. MC02 and others:

  • Punkt. MC02 – A Privacy-First Minimalist Smartphone: Swiss company Punkt made waves back in 2018 with the Punkt MP02, a tiny 4G “dumbphone” designed by Jasper Morrison. Now Punkt has launched the MC02, which is essentially its first full-fledged smartphone – albeit one laser-focused on privacy and minimalist software. The Punkt MC02 (released in early 2024) looks like a conventional 6.7″ smartphone, but runs a custom Android fork called Apostrophy OS that prioritizes security and restraint techcrunch.com techcrunch.com. Hardware-wise, the MC02 is a mid-range device: it features a 6.67″ FHD+ IPS display, MediaTek Dimensity 900 chipset, 6 GB RAM, 128 GB storage (plus microSD), and surprisingly, a triple-camera system (64 MP main, 8 MP ultrawide, 2 MP macro) tomsguide.com tomsguide.com. It even has modern perks like NFC, a fingerprint reader, dual SIM, and a large 5,500 mAh battery with wireless charging support techcrunch.com. In raw specs it far outguns the Light, Wise, or Mudita phones – however, Punkt’s aim isn’t specs for their own sake. Strategically, the MC02 diverges from devices like Light Phone by allowing more functionality but in a privacy-guarded way. Apostrophy OS (developed in Switzerland alongside Punkt) is built on GrapheneOS – a renowned open-source secure OS – meaning the phone is Google-free, encryption-hardened, and gives users fine control over app permissions techcrunch.com. The OS includes a suite of secure services: for example, a built-in VPN (“Digital Nomad”) that runs at the system level to encrypt all traffic techcrunch.com, and an intuitive privacy dashboard that logs and lets you control what each app is doing tomsguide.com. Punkt’s founder Petter Neby emphasizes that “it’s software that makes the difference” – the hardware is intentionally generic so as not to distract; the focus is on the OS’s privacy ethos techcrunch.com. Unlike the other minimalist phones, the MC02 can install and run regular Android apps (via secure APK repositories or possibly a limited store) – but the expectation is that users will choose carefully. It does not come with Google Play; instead, you can install privacy-respecting alternatives or use web apps. Punkt’s philosophy is minimalism through privacy and intentional choice, rather than outright removal of all apps. For example, you could use an encrypted email app or Signal on the MC02, but the OS will prevent data harvesting and nag you to review permissions. One catch: Subscription. Punkt sells the MC02 for $749 (≈€699/£599) and that includes 1 year of Apostrophy Services; after that, if you want the full suite (VPN, encrypted cloud sync, etc.), it’s about $17–20 per month tomsguide.com techcrunch.com. The phone will work without subscribing (it won’t “brick”), but you lose the value-added privacy services techcrunch.com. This is similar to Wisephone’s model, though Punkt’s pitch is more about paying for privacy instead of your data. Reception: Early reviews of the Punkt MC02 have been mixed. TechCrunch admired the concept, calling it a device at “the crossroads of utility, privacy and minimalism,” noting that it caters to a small subset of users who want a smartphone minus Big Tech intrusion techcrunch.com techcrunch.com. Tom’s Guide, however, gave a scathing review, citing “buggy software,” “terrible camera,” and an “extremely dim screen” – ultimately saying they “haven’t been this annoyed by a phone in a long time” tomsguide.com tomsguide.com. Clearly, the MC02’s execution may need refinement. But Punkt’s strategy is noteworthy: they are effectively creating a secure smartphone that remains minimalist by not vying for your attention. The MC02 is available now (shipping worldwide since mid-2024), and Punkt intends to improve it via updates. They also aim to license Apostrophy OS to other manufacturers – so we might see more brands release “privacy phones” based on this platform in coming years techcrunch.com techcrunch.com. Who it’s for: The Punkt MC02 (and its future derivatives) will appeal to those who find the Light Phone too limiting but still want to escape the surveillance capitalism of normal smartphones. It’s like a de-Googled Pixel with a safety net. Expect its niche to grow as privacy concerns rise.
  • Keyphone – Crowdfunded Minimalism with Multiple Models: On the horizon for late 2025 is the Keyphone, one of the most anticipated minimalist phones in the community keyphone.tech. Keyphone is interesting because it’s an independent project that offers three different form factors under one platform: a T9 keypad model (monochrome display, old-school texting), a Hybrid model (small touch screen + numeric keypad), and a Touch-only model keyphone.tech. The idea is to give users choice in how “dumb” or modern they want their phone’s interface to be. All versions run a custom OS built from scratch (not just Android skinned) keyphone.tech, aiming to include just the “modern basics” – things like calls, SMS, contacts, calendar, music, camera, notes, and even navigation – but without app stores or endless feeds keyphone.tech keyphone.tech. Uniquely, Keyphone touts a modular design: for example, it will let users swap out the camera module for an upgraded one easily keyphone.tech, and it has programmable physical buttons to quickly access certain functions keyphone.tech. This modularity and customization angle sets it apart (it sounds a bit like Fairphone meets Light Phone). Keyphone is currently being launched via Indiegogo, with an early bird price around $249 and an eventual retail of $399 keyphone.tech keyphone.tech. It’s slated to ship to backers by late 2025. Strategically, Keyphone is positioning itself against the notion that all minimalist phones are underpowered or outdated. It claims to have “custom hardware, custom OS” built ground-up for this purpose keyphone.tech – not a repurposed feature phone or a simple Android mod. If it delivers, it could attract those who haven’t jumped to Light or Mudita due to missing certain form factors (some people really want physical keys, for instance). Keyphone also emphasizes being an independent, community-driven effort (they even have surveys influencing R&D) keyphone.tech. Time will tell if it lives up to the hype, but it’s one to watch as a “promising dumbphone of 2025” keyphone.tech.
  • Balance Phone – Europe’s Take on a Teen-Safe Phone: The Balance Phone is a new entrant (launched in early 2025) from a Barcelona-based startup, and it parallels the Wisephone concept. In fact, Balance partnered with Samsung to produce a phone that is essentially a Samsung handset running Balance’s minimalist OS catalannews.com catalannews.com. Their focus is on fighting screen addiction by blocking all addictive content – social media, games, porn, etc. – while keeping “essential” apps that add value like banking, maps, or educational tools catalannews.com catalannews.com. The Balance Phone’s interface is intentionally “boring” and simple, and it aims to promote “intentionality” – you only open apps when you really need them catalannews.com catalannews.com. Initially, Balance offered just an app (a launcher) that could turn any Android into a minimalist phone, but realizing kids could bypass it, they moved to selling actual devices with the system baked in (irreversible without a full wipe) catalannews.com. The target demographic is very much children and teenagers – they frame it as an alternative to banning phones for kids, giving parents a middle ground catalannews.com catalannews.com. In Spain, for instance, a lot of Balance’s early users are aged 9–16 catalannews.com. Hardware is likely a mid-range Samsung (perhaps Galaxy A54) with 5G, to make sure it’s fully functional but not cutting-edge. Balance uses a subscription model too (they even had an app subscription around €7.99/month when it was just an app). The co-founders, in interviews, emphasize that this is “not a product for the masses, but for people aware of their addiction and ready to address it.” catalannews.com We can expect Balance Phone to expand beyond Spain if successful, and they’ll join forces with concerned parent communities in Europe. Strategic difference: Balance is heavily youth-focused in its marketing, whereas Wisephone (its closest analog) also markets to general audiences and families. Both share the idea of partnering with known hardware (Samsung) and using a curated Android. It shows a trend that major manufacturers might indirectly get involved (Samsung providing devices for these niche OSes) – a sign that the big companies see the niche growing.
  • Others Rumored or Upcoming: We’re also hearing about other projects. For instance, the Boring Phone out of New Zealand (which in 2019 offered a de-Googled Android phone without an app store) might see a 2025 refresh or new software updates. Nokia (HMD Global) has been consistently releasing “feature phones” with modern 4G, and while not strictly minimalist smartphones, devices like the Nokia 6300 4G or the revived Nokia 3310 show there’s still interest in simpler phones techcrunch.com. It’s possible Nokia or another manufacturer could launch a “hybrid” phone with a custom minimal OS – none confirmed yet, but HMD did announce plans to develop non-Android software for some future devices, which could lean minimalist. Light Phone 4? Light has not announced a successor yet (the Light Phone III just rolled out), but if their history is any guide, they will likely iterate, perhaps adding things like the currently missing features (maybe a Light Phone III software update will activate those, and a future Light Phone IV could add something like a color e-ink display or other refinements – purely speculative). Mudita’s roadmap: After Kompakt’s launch, Mudita might consider adding a 5G model or a variant with a larger e-ink or different form, but again nothing public yet. Software solutions: In the meantime, there are also apps/launchers like the Mode phone/launcher, Unpluq, and minimalist launchers that can turn standard smartphones into quasi-dumbphones. These aren’t separate devices, but they indicate a growing interest in “minimal mode” that might eventually be offered by mainstream OS – even Google and Apple have introduced Focus modes. So the trend is acknowledged industry-wide.

In summary, the minimalist phone space in 2025 and beyond is getting more diverse. From Punkt’s high-security smartphone to crowdfunded devices with new form factors, there’s momentum building. Not all will succeed – some may remain niche or struggle (as early reviews of some devices warn) – but the fact that multiple approaches are being tried is good news for consumers seeking an escape from the smartphone rat race. The upcoming models differ strategically: some, like Punkt MC02, aim to give you a full smartphone experience minus surveillance; others, like Keyphone and Balance, aim to redesign the phone experience altogether with new hardware or by targeting specific groups. It shows that “minimalist phone” no longer has a one-size-fits-all definition. As we move forward, expect the lines between “dumb” and “smart” to blur – you may have phones that are smartly dumb or dumbly smart, depending on philosophy. What’s clear is that a segment of users is willing to trade features (and pay money) for peace of mind and time well spent. And companies old and new are listening, making 2025 an exciting time for those looking to reclaim their attention, one phone at a time.

Sources:

I Have A Problem with the Light Phone III
Watch this video on YouTube.

Tags: , ,

LIM Center, Aleje Jerozolimskie 65/79, 00-697 Warsaw, Poland

ts@ts2.pl

+48 (22) 364 58 00

© 2025 TS2 SPACE Sp. z o.o.

This site uses cookies to deliver services in accordance with the Privacy Policy. You can specify the conditions for storage or access to cookies in your browser.