NEW YORK, December 31, 2025, 19:28 ET — After-hours
- Carvana shares were down about 1.7% at $422.02 in after-hours trading.
- The stock traded between $421.95 and $430.30 in the session, with about 1.6 million shares changing hands.
- U.S. stocks slipped in the final session of 2025 in holiday-thin trade, with markets closed Thursday for New Year’s Day. Reuters
Carvana Co. shares slipped in after-hours trading on Wednesday, ending the final session of 2025 lower as investors wrapped up the year with light liquidity and a broad pullback in U.S. equities.
The move matters now because Carvana has become a high-volatility consumer name, and year-end trading tends to magnify swings as funds rebalance and tax-driven positioning fades. Thin volumes can exaggerate price moves in stocks that have been heavily traded through the year.
With U.S. markets shut on Thursday for New Year’s Day, investors are looking to Friday’s reopen for signs of whether risk appetite returns quickly in early January, or whether year-end profit-taking carries over into 2026.
Wall Street’s major indexes ended lower in the final trading session of 2025, with the S&P 500 down 0.74% and the Nasdaq down 0.76%, while volume stayed below recent averages in the holiday-shortened week, a Reuters market wrap showed. “I do not expect that the last few days will have so much bearing on the performance of the next year,” said Giuseppe Sette, co-founder and president of Reflexivity, pointing to profit-taking opportunities when liquidity was low. Reuters
Carvana’s stock — often treated as a high-beta proxy for consumer credit and growth sentiment — moved in step with that late-year de-risking. After-hours trading refers to transactions after the 4 p.m. ET closing bell, when liquidity is typically thinner than during the regular session.
Used-vehicle and auto-retail names were broadly lower on the day. CarMax fell 1.7%, while ACV Auctions lost 1.5% and OPENLANE slid 1.1%, according to MarketWatch data. MarketWatch
Carvana has been in focus since it was selected to join the S&P 500 in December, a milestone that came after a sharp turnaround from its 2022 downturn as the online used-car retailer tightened costs and benefited from improved demand, Reuters reported. Reuters
Investors are also watching the rate outlook. The Federal Reserve meets on Jan. 27-28, with investors expecting the central bank to leave its benchmark rate unchanged, according to a Reuters report on Tuesday. Reuters
For Carvana, the calendar turns quickly to earnings season. Nasdaq lists Carvana’s next earnings report date as an estimate of Feb. 18, 2026, noting the timing is derived from an algorithm and is not a company-confirmed date. Nasdaq
Traders will be listening for any update on demand and profitability trends that drive the equity story, including retail unit volumes and gross profit per retail unit — the amount earned per car sold before overhead — as well as any commentary on funding conditions in a still-rate-sensitive consumer environment.
Near term, the stock’s direction may hinge less on company headlines than on whether Friday’s reopening brings fresh risk-taking after a choppy, low-liquidity finish to the year.
