NEW YORK, December 30, 2025, 21:29 ET — Market closed
Carvana Co. shares fell 0.9% on Tuesday to close at $429.55, after trading between $429.05 and $435.70. Volume was about 1.33 million shares, and the stock was little changed in after-hours trading, which takes place electronically after the 4 p.m. close. 1
The dip matters because Carvana has become a high-beta, heavily traded name after a sharp run this year, making it sensitive to shifts in risk appetite. The online used-car retailer also sits at the intersection of consumer demand and borrowing costs, with financing central to how many buyers fund vehicle purchases.
The stock’s investor base has also broadened after its move into the S&P 500 earlier this month, which typically forces index-tracking funds to buy shares. S&P Dow Jones Indices said the change would take effect on Dec. 22. 2
Tuesday’s pullback came as Wall Street ended slightly lower in choppy year-end trade, with investors parsing minutes from the Federal Reserve’s December meeting and watching rate expectations. “It’s just a healthy rebalancing of allocations more so than an emotionally driven sell-off,” said Mark Hackett, chief market strategist at Nationwide, as trading stayed thin into the end of the year. 3
Used-car retail shares were mixed. CarMax rose about 0.4%, while AutoNation slipped about 0.6% at the close.
Carvana’s decline extended a late-December fade after a volatile stretch around the S&P rebalancing window. The stock has tested the low-$420s in recent sessions, after pushing as high as $458.25 on Dec. 22 and topping $485.33 earlier in the month, according to Investing.com data. 4
For investors, the question is whether the stock’s momentum can hold as borrowing-cost headlines drive daily positioning. Carvana’s model depends on sourcing and selling used vehicles while managing financing and funding, leaving sentiment tied to the path of rates and credit conditions.
Some traders also point to liquidity, not headlines, as the near-term driver. With fewer participants around year-end, relatively small orders can move high-priced, high-volatility stocks more than usual.
Before Wednesday’s session, chart-focused traders will be watching whether Carvana can hold the late-December floor near $424 and reclaim the $440 area, after Tuesday’s close near the day’s low. That band has defined much of the post–S&P-inclusion trading range. 4
Macro attention is likely to stay on interest-rate expectations after the Fed’s minutes, with any move in Treasury yields feeding into views on auto-loan affordability and demand. Thin liquidity may keep intraday swings sharp even without company-specific headlines.
The next clear company catalyst is earnings. Carvana has not announced a date, but MarketBeat estimates its next report for Feb. 18, after the market close, based on past reporting patterns. 5
When that report arrives, investors are expected to focus on unit volumes, profitability per vehicle and cash generation — metrics that have helped drive the stock’s re-rating over the past year. In the meantime, traders said the stock’s ability to hold late-December support levels may set the tone into the final session of 2025.
