As of December 5, 2025, FirstEnergy stock sits near multi‑year highs, but a fresh $250 million HB6 penalty and new rate rulings in Ohio mean the story is far from risk‑free.
Snapshot: Where FirstEnergy Stock Stands on 5 December 2025
FirstEnergy Corp. (NYSE: FE) is trading just below its recent 52‑week high after a strong 2025 rally.
- Latest close: about $45.14 per share (Dec. 4, 2025), down a fraction (‑0.2%) on the day. [1]
- 52‑week range: roughly $37.58 – $48.20. [2]
- Valuation: trailing P/E ~20.8, with a forward P/E around 17–18 based on 2025 EPS expectations. [3]
- Dividend yield: annual dividend of $1.78 per share (quarterly $0.445) for a yield of about 3.7–3.9%, depending on the trading price. [4]
- Volatility:beta ~0.53, meaning FE typically moves about half as much as the broader market. [5]
A recent analysis on Yahoo Finance noted that FirstEnergy has delivered roughly a 19.6% price gain in 2025 so far, before dividends – a strong move for a traditionally defensive utility. [6]
From a technical perspective, data from StockInvest shows FE slipping slightly over the past two weeks (‑2.4%) but still in a longer‑term uptrend, with relatively low day‑to‑day volatility of around 1.8%. [7]
The Big Overhang: HB6 Bribery Fallout and Ohio Penalties
The main headline shaping the FirstEnergy narrative this week isn’t its share price, but the latest chapter in the House Bill 6 (HB6) bribery scandal in Ohio.
$250 million in new penalties and refunds
In late November, the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) issued landmark rulings tied to HB6, ordering FirstEnergy’s three Ohio utilities to pay roughly $250.7 million for regulatory violations linked to the scandal. [8]
Key points from those rulings:
- More than $186 million of the penalty is to be refunded or credited to consumers. [9]
- The action is one of the largest utility misconduct penalties in U.S. history. [10]
- On the same day, PUCO approved a new rate package that results in:
- A smaller‑than‑requested rate increase for Cleveland Electric Illuminating customers (about +$76 million annually).
- Rate cuts of roughly $24.4 million and $17.4 million per year for Toledo Edison and Ohio Edison customers, respectively. [11]
Net‑net, regulators granted around $34 million in total annual rate increases, far short of the approximately $183 million FirstEnergy initially sought. [12]
$108 million in “errors” FirstEnergy wants customers to pay
Adding to investor unease, an investigative report published via the Ohio Capital Journal and News 5 Cleveland detailed how federal audits found FirstEnergy misclassified around $108 million in lobbying, advertising and political donations as construction costs between 2015 and 2021. [13]
Because utilities are typically allowed to earn a profit on construction investments—but not on lobbying or political spending—this misclassification potentially allowed FirstEnergy to over‑recover from ratepayers. [14]
Crucially, the company has asked regulators for permission to bill customers for these costs. If that request is denied, FirstEnergy has warned in its SEC filings that absorbing the charges could have “an adverse impact” on its financial condition. [15]
Why the scandal still matters for FE stock
Although FirstEnergy already paid $230 million to resolve federal criminal charges, $100 million to settle SEC securities claims, and about $20 million to avoid state criminal charges, plus nearly $50 million to settle a shareholder class action, the HB6 saga continues to influence rate cases and regulatory scrutiny. [16]
For shareholders, that means:
- Ongoing reputational risk, which can influence regulatory decisions and political pressure.
- Potential disallowances of costs in future rate cases, especially in Ohio, as consumer advocates push to shift more burden from customers to shareholders. [17]
- A non‑zero chance of additional financial hits if regulators or courts revisit past practices.
This regulatory cloud is one of the main reasons some analysts, like KeyBanc’s Sophie Karp, cite “rising rate‑case and regulatory risks” in Ohio and New Jersey as a key factor behind their more cautious stance on the stock. [18]
Earnings and Growth: Solid Fundamentals Behind the Noise
Despite its political and regulatory baggage, FirstEnergy’s operating performance in 2025 has been strong.
Q3 2025: Earnings beat and raised guidance
In its third‑quarter 2025 results, FirstEnergy reported: [19]
- GAAP EPS: $0.76 (vs. $0.73 a year earlier).
- Core (non‑GAAP) EPS: $0.83 (vs. $0.76 a year earlier), up 9% year‑over‑year.
- Revenue: $4.1 billion (vs. $3.7 billion in Q3 2024), up about 10.8%.
On the back of those results, management:
- Narrowed 2025 Core EPS guidance to $2.50–$2.56, in the upper half of its original $2.40–$2.60 range. [20]
- Increased 2025 capital spending guidance from $5.0 billion to $5.5 billion, having already deployed more than $4 billion through September. [21]
- Reaffirmed a 6–8% compound annual Core EPS growth rate target from 2025–2029 and a targeted 10–12% annual total shareholder return when including the dividend. [22]
Equity research compiled by MarketBeat broadly confirms these numbers and notes that analysts expect FirstEnergy to earn about $2.66 per share in 2025. [23]
At a share price in the mid‑$40s, that implies a forward P/E in the high teens, slightly above the typical range for regulated utilities but not out of line considering FE’s capital investment runway and earnings growth targets.
The Investment Plan: Energize365, Data Centers and New Generation
Beyond the courtroom drama, the structural story for FirstEnergy is about modernizing an aging grid and preparing for a surge in electricity demand—especially from data centers and electrification.
Energize365: $28 billion grid modernization through 2029
FirstEnergy’s long‑term grid program, Energize365, aims to create a “smarter, more secure and more reliable” system across its territories in Ohio, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, West Virginia, Maryland and New York. [24]
Key pieces of the plan:
- $4.5 billion invested in 2024, about 20% more than 2023.
- An additional $28 billion of investment planned between 2025 and 2029. [25]
- Heavy focus on:
The company’s Q3 investor deck suggests transmission investments are expected to rise by about 30% in its next five‑year plan, with total rate base projected to more than double by 2030, especially across FERC‑regulated transmission assets. [28]
Data center demand and a 45% peak‑load jump
In a November feature, Utility Dive reported that FirstEnergy expects peak load across its territories to rise roughly 45% by 2035, driven largely by data centers and AI‑related compute demand. [29]
Management has warned that current wholesale market structures and PJM capacity auctions are pushing customer bills higher without reliably attracting enough new generation, and has argued for reforms to keep demand growth manageable and affordable. [30]
West Virginia: 1,200 MW gas plant plus solar
To meet that growth, FirstEnergy has proposed a major new generation project in West Virginia:
- A 1,200‑MW combined‑cycle natural gas plant plus about 70 MW of utility‑scale solar. [31]
- Estimated construction cost of roughly $2.5 billion if FirstEnergy builds it itself. [32]
- Construction phase expected to support more than 3,260 jobs and generate about $68 million in state and local tax revenue; ongoing operations could support roughly 2,200 jobs and $85.9 million in annual tax receipts. [33]
FirstEnergy plans to file for regulatory approval in early 2026 via its Mon Power and Potomac Edison subsidiaries. If green‑lit, the company expects to invest $5.2 billion in West Virginia infrastructure between 2025 and 2029, plus the additional $2.5 billion tied to the plant itself. [34]
New Jersey and local reliability upgrades
On the distribution side, subsidiary JCP&L is investing $108 million through 2028 to strengthen the grid in fast‑growing Ocean County, New Jersey—adding transformers, strengthening lines, and installing more than 200 “TripSaver” devices that automatically restore power after temporary faults. [35]
These projects are part of EnergizeNJ, a state‑approved program nested under the broader Energize365 umbrella and aimed at hardening the system against storms and supporting rapid population and load growth in the region. [36]
Reliability, Outages and Customer Perception
Grid investments are partly a response to very visible reliability challenges.
On December 5, 2025, News 5 Cleveland reported more than 10,000 customers in Northeast Ohio without power amid a “transmission outage,” with FirstEnergy crews racing to restore service. [37]
While such outages are not unusual in a large T&D network, they:
- Reinforce political and regulatory pressure to raise reliability standards.
- Provide ammunition to consumer advocates who argue that FirstEnergy’s high spending and previous mismanagement haven’t always translated into service quality improvements. [38]
From an ESG and public‑relations perspective, FE has highlighted philanthropic work like a $10,000 grant from the FirstEnergy Foundation to York College of Pennsylvania to support electrical engineering education, positioning itself as a partner in workforce development. [39]
This sort of community support doesn’t directly move the stock, but it does contribute to the company’s efforts to rebuild trust after HB6.
Dividend Profile: Income Now, Modest Growth Later
For many investors, FirstEnergy is an income stock first and foremost.
- Quarterly dividend: $0.445 per share; annualized $1.78. [40]
- Yield: about 3.7–3.9%, depending on the share price on a given day. [41]
- Payout ratio: around 78% of earnings, based on current year estimates. [42]
FirstEnergy has a long history of paying dividends, and KeyBanc pointed out that the company has maintained a dividend streak stretching back nearly three decades. [43]
Management’s stated target of 6–8% annual EPS growth through 2029, combined with this dividend, suggests room for modest dividend increases over time—assuming regulators allow sufficient returns on the company’s planned capital spending and no major new HB6‑related charges erode earnings. [44]
What Wall Street Analysts Are Saying About FE Stock
Consensus: “Moderate Buy” with mid‑single‑digit upside
According to a late November survey by MarketBeat:
- 14 analysts currently cover FirstEnergy.
- Overall rating: “Moderate Buy”.
- 1 Strong Buy
- 7 Buy
- 6 Hold
- Average 12‑month price target: about $49.08 per share. [45]
With FE trading in the mid‑$40s, that implies mid‑ to high‑single‑digit capital gains potential, plus the nearly 4% dividend yield.
Major recent calls include: [46]
- Barclays: upgraded from Equal Weight to Overweight, raising its target from $43 to $49, citing an underappreciated growth plan.
- Mizuho: target raised from $45 to $50 with a Neutral rating.
- Jefferies: target lifted from $45 to $47, rating Hold.
- UBS: target increased from $47 to $50, rating Neutral.
- KeyBanc: downgraded FE from Overweight to Sector Weight (essentially neutral), arguing the valuation premium leaves less room for upside given Ohio rate‑case risks and rising regulatory concerns in New Jersey. [47]
Institutional flows: Some buying, some profit‑taking
A series of recent 13F‑based reports shows heavy institutional involvement:
- Overall, institutions own roughly 89% of FirstEnergy’s outstanding shares. [48]
- OMERS Administration Corp increased its FE stake by about 219% in Q2 2025, now holding over 62,000 shares. [49]
- Edgestream Partners L.P. boosted its position by roughly 1,380%, to about 115,000 shares. [50]
- Others, like Lumbard & Kellner LLC and 1832 Asset Management, have trimmed their stakes, taking profits after the stock’s strong run. [51]
Taken together, this flow data paints a picture of broad institutional confidence, with some rotation as the stock approaches analyst targets and valuation “fair value” levels.
Technical Signals and Options Market Sentiment
Chart‑based forecast
StockInvest’s daily technical model currently rates FE as a “hold/accumulate”:
- The stock has eased modestly in recent sessions but remains in a broader upward trend, with price still above its 200‑day moving average. [52]
- Their three‑month forecast suggests an expected gain of roughly 6.8%, with a 90% probability band projecting the share price in the $48–$51 range over that horizon (not a guarantee, just a statistical model). [53]
Options market: Implied volatility is ticking up
Zacks has flagged a recent surge in implied volatility for FirstEnergy stock options, a sign that traders are pricing in larger‑than‑usual near‑term moves in the share price. [54]
Higher implied volatility can reflect:
- Anticipation of upcoming regulatory decisions,
- Market uncertainty around rate cases or legislation, or
- Simply increased demand for options as the stock hovers near long‑term highs.
For long‑term investors, this is less about day‑to‑day price noise and more a reminder that headline risk around rate rulings, HB6 developments or capex approvals can create sharp, short‑term swings in FE’s share price.
Key Risks for FirstEnergy Shareholders
Even with solid earnings and a visible growth plan, FirstEnergy’s risk profile is more complex than that of many utilities:
- Regulatory and legal risk (HB6 and beyond)
- Ongoing fallout from HB6, including the recent $250.7 million PUCO penalties and the dispute over misclassified costs, could continue to pressure returns and limit allowed rate increases. [55]
- Future rate cases, especially in Ohio
- FirstEnergy has already signaled that its Ohio utilities plan to file their next major rate case in early 2026, with new rates potentially effective by 2027. [56]
- Consumer advocates are pushing for lower allowed returns to reflect past mismanagement, which could weigh on earnings if regulators agree. [57]
- Execution risk on a very large capex program
- Energize365 and the West Virginia generation proposal together represent tens of billions of dollars in planned spending. Cost overruns, project delays or unfavorable regulatory decisions could erode the expected 6–8% EPS CAGR. [58]
- Balance sheet and interest‑rate exposure
- MarketBeat data shows FE with a debt‑to‑equity ratio of about 1.8, typical for utilities but still a constraint if rates stay elevated or regulators limit recovery. [59]
- Reputation and political pressure
- HB6, power outages and high bills have led to growing political scrutiny in multiple states. That can translate into tighter oversight, lower allowed ROEs or stricter conditions on future projects. [60]
Bull Case: Why Some Investors Still Like FE at These Levels
On the other side of the ledger, the bullish argument for FirstEnergy stock looks like this:
- Predictable, regulated cash flows from distribution and transmission assets in several states. [61]
- A massive, mostly regulated investment pipeline (Energize365, West Virginia generation, EnergizeNJ) that, if executed well, expands rate base and earnings over many years. [62]
- A 3.8%‑ish dividend yield backed by relatively stable earnings and targeted EPS growth of 6–8%, implying potential high single‑digit to low double‑digit total returns if everything goes right. [63]
- Broad institutional support, with nearly 90% of the float in professional hands and several large funds increasing positions in 2025. [64]
- A multi‑year structural demand tailwind from data centers, EVs and electrification in PJM and neighboring markets, where FirstEnergy is a major player. [65]
In other words: for investors who can tolerate regulatory risk, FE offers defensive income plus measured growth, rather than fast‑money upside.
Bottom Line: How to Read FirstEnergy Stock on December 5, 2025
As of December 5, 2025, FirstEnergy sits at an interesting crossroads:
- Financially, it is delivering earnings beats, raising guidance and laying out a credible plan to grow EPS 6–8% annually through at least 2029. [66]
- Strategically, it has a massive grid‑modernization and generation‑build program aimed squarely at the long‑term wave of electrification and data‑center demand. [67]
- Regulatorily, it’s still paying for past sins, with fresh fines, contested cost recovery and future rate cases that could tilt either in favor of customers or shareholders. [68]
With a consensus “Moderate Buy” rating, a price target in the high‑$40s, and a near‑4% dividend, Wall Street clearly sees some upside left—but not without meaningful risk. [69]
For anyone considering FE:
- Think of it as a regulation‑heavy, income‑oriented utility with a growth tilt, not a pure “bond proxy.”
- Pay attention to Ohio and West Virginia regulatory dockets in 2026, along with any new HB6‑related developments.
- Be prepared for headline‑driven volatility, even though the business itself is relatively stable.
Important: This article is for informational and news purposes only and does not constitute investment, legal or tax advice. Always do your own research and consider consulting a qualified financial adviser before making investment decisions.
References
1. stockinvest.us, 2. www.marketbeat.com, 3. www.marketbeat.com, 4. www.marketbeat.com, 5. www.marketbeat.com, 6. finance.yahoo.com, 7. stockinvest.us, 8. www.canarymedia.com, 9. www.canarymedia.com, 10. www.canarymedia.com, 11. www.canarymedia.com, 12. www.canarymedia.com, 13. www.news5cleveland.com, 14. www.news5cleveland.com, 15. www.news5cleveland.com, 16. www.canarymedia.com, 17. www.canarymedia.com, 18. www.investing.com, 19. www.firstenergycorp.com, 20. www.firstenergycorp.com, 21. www.firstenergycorp.com, 22. s27.q4cdn.com, 23. www.marketbeat.com, 24. www.firstenergycorp.com, 25. www.firstenergycorp.com, 26. www.firstenergycorp.com, 27. www.firstenergycorp.com, 28. s27.q4cdn.com, 29. www.utilitydive.com, 30. www.utilitydive.com, 31. investors.firstenergycorp.com, 32. investors.firstenergycorp.com, 33. investors.firstenergycorp.com, 34. investors.firstenergycorp.com, 35. www.firstenergycorp.com, 36. www.firstenergycorp.com, 37. www.news5cleveland.com, 38. www.canarymedia.com, 39. seekingalpha.com, 40. www.marketbeat.com, 41. www.marketbeat.com, 42. www.marketbeat.com, 43. www.investing.com, 44. s27.q4cdn.com, 45. www.marketbeat.com, 46. www.marketbeat.com, 47. www.investing.com, 48. www.marketbeat.com, 49. www.marketbeat.com, 50. www.marketbeat.com, 51. www.marketbeat.com, 52. stockinvest.us, 53. stockinvest.us, 54. www.zacks.com, 55. www.canarymedia.com, 56. www.canarymedia.com, 57. www.canarymedia.com, 58. s27.q4cdn.com, 59. www.marketbeat.com, 60. www.canarymedia.com, 61. www.marketbeat.com, 62. s27.q4cdn.com, 63. s27.q4cdn.com, 64. www.marketbeat.com, 65. www.utilitydive.com, 66. www.firstenergycorp.com, 67. www.firstenergycorp.com, 68. www.canarymedia.com, 69. www.marketbeat.com
