NEW YORK, Dec 31, 2025, 6:41 PM ET — After-hours
- PayPal traded lower into the year-end close as U.S. stocks finished the day in the red.
- Payment names moved with broader risk sentiment and a rise in Treasury yields.
- Focus turns to early-January economic data and PayPal’s next earnings window.
PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL) shares were down 1.2% at $58.38 in after-hours trading on Wednesday, when stocks changed hands outside the regular 9:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. ET session. The stock traded between $58.30 and $59.21 and saw about 13.0 million shares in volume, with the shares valued at roughly 13 times trailing earnings, a standard price-to-earnings measure.
The move matters now because liquidity typically dries up into the final session of the year, leaving even modest flows to move prices. Investors also use the calendar turn to reset exposure after tax-loss selling, fund rebalancing and performance-driven positioning.
For payments companies such as PayPal, the rate backdrop is a constant crosscurrent. Higher Treasury yields can pressure the valuation of growth-leaning stocks by raising the discount rate investors apply to future profits.
Peers were also lower in late trade. Visa was down 0.8% and Mastercard fell 1.1%, underscoring the broad tone across the payments group.
U.S. stocks ended 2025’s last session lower, with the S&P 500 down 0.7% and the Nasdaq off 0.8%, as trading stayed thin ahead of the holiday, according to the Associated Press. “It’s the long-term AI optimism … that’s kept optimism alive,” said Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist at CFRA, pointing to themes that carried markets through a turbulent year. 1
Investors also navigated a holiday-altered schedule. Bond markets closed early at 2 p.m. ET on Wednesday and U.S. stock markets are shut on Thursday for New Year’s Day, MarketWatch reported. 2
Options activity hinted at traders looking beyond the holiday, with new February 2026 options contracts in PYPL becoming available on Wednesday, Nasdaq reported. 3
The next major company-specific catalyst is PayPal’s quarterly update. Wall Street Horizon lists PayPal’s next earnings date as unconfirmed for Tuesday, Feb. 3, before the market opens. 4
Investors will watch for signs that PayPal can expand checkout usage and keep margins steady while spending on product and fraud prevention. They will also look at transaction margin dollars — PayPal’s measure of profit generated from processing payments after transaction-related costs — as a key read on the quality of growth.
Macro data between now and earnings may set the tone for fintech valuations. The Bureau of Labor Statistics schedules the Employment Situation report for December 2025 for Jan. 9 at 8:30 a.m. ET, a release that can move Treasury yields and rate expectations. 5
Technically, traders often watch the day’s low and high as near-term markers. For PayPal, $58.30 and $59.21 bracketed Wednesday’s range, levels that can act as short-term support and resistance in the first sessions of 2026.
When U.S. markets reopen after the holiday, investors will be watching whether PYPL keeps tracking the broader payments group — and whether moves in yields continue to dictate the day-to-day tape for rate-sensitive stocks.
