Carvana Co. (NYSE: CVNA) is back in the spotlight. On Monday, December 8, 2025, the online used-car retailer’s shares surged again after S&P Dow Jones Indices confirmed that Carvana will join the benchmark S&P 500 index on December 22, 2025. The stock traded around $454 in late session, up roughly 14% on the day and near record highs, capping a year in which the stock has gained well over 100% and staged one of the most dramatic recoveries in recent market history. [1]
According to Reuters, Carvana’s market value has swelled to roughly $87 billion, now exceeding both Ford and General Motors, and the shares trade at about 57 times forward earnings — a valuation more typical of high‑growth software than a used-car dealer. [2]
Below is a rundown of the key news, forecasts and analyses on Carvana stock as of December 8, 2025, and what they may mean for investors and traders tracking CVNA.
Carvana Stock Today: Price Action on December 8, 2025
- Latest price: roughly $454 per share, with an intraday high just below $455.
- Daily move: around +13–14% on the session following the S&P 500 announcement. [3]
- Year-to-date performance: Carvana is up about 115–120% in 2025, vastly outpacing the S&P 500’s mid‑teens gain this year. [4]
- Multi‑year recovery: From its 2022 lows during a near‑bankruptcy scare, the stock has surged more than 8,000%, according to Reuters. [5]
Financial news outlets including Barron’s and Investor’s Business Daily highlight that today’s rally pushed CVNA to fresh record territory, with momentum intensifying once the S&P 500 inclusion was confirmed. [6]
S&P 500 Inclusion: The Catalyst Behind the Rally
S&P Dow Jones Indices announced that Carvana will be added to the S&P 500 index effective December 22, 2025, replacing another constituent. [7]
Why this matters:
- Forced buying by index funds: Index‑tracking mutual funds and ETFs benchmarked to the S&P 500 will need to buy CVNA shares ahead of the effective date. This mechanically creates extra demand for the stock in the short term. [8]
- Signal of survivorship and scale: Joining the S&P 500 signals that Carvana has reached a certain size, liquidity, and profitability threshold — a stark contrast to the existential questions swirling around the company in 2022. [9]
- Re‑rating potential: Some analysts, including Bank of America, explicitly cited index inclusion as a key catalyst and have since raised their price targets. [10]
Today’s move is consistent with that dynamic: Carvana’s stock jumped roughly 9–13% immediately after the S&P 500 news hit the tape, according to multiple intraday reports. [11]
From Near‑Bankruptcy to Index Giant: Carvana’s Turnaround Story
Just three years ago, Carvana was widely considered a near‑failure. In 2022:
- The company was heavily shorted, with more than half its free float sold short at peak pessimism. [12]
- Weak used‑car demand, rising interest rates and a large debt load sparked worries about potential bankruptcy. [13]
Since then, several key changes have unfolded:
- Debt restructuring and balance sheet repair
- Carvana struck a series of debt exchange agreements with noteholders starting in 2023 and continuing into 2025, reducing total debt by more than $1.2 billion and pushing out maturities. [14]
- As of September 2025, estimates from several data providers put Carvana’s total debt at roughly $5.6–5.7 billion, down from prior peaks. [15]
- S&P Global recently upgraded Carvana’s credit ratings, lifting senior secured debt to BB‑ and unsecured debt to B, reflecting improved financial resilience. [16]
- Aggressive cost control and operational efficiency
Carvana tightened expenses, optimized logistics and reconditioning operations, and leaned on data‑driven pricing to improve unit economics, according to company filings and shareholder letters. [17] - Return to profitability and scale
The company is now growing volume and posting meaningful profits, a combination that underpins the current bull case and justifies, in analysts’ eyes, at least part of the lofty valuation. [18]
In short, Carvana has pivoted from a distressed, highly shorted name to an S&P 500 constituent with improving credit quality and positive earnings — but at a price that assumes continued near‑flawless execution.
Earnings Momentum: Record Q3 2025 Results
Carvana’s fundamental story is anchored in a string of strong quarters. The company reported record Q3 2025 results on October 29. [19]
Key highlights from Q3 2025:
- Retail units sold: 155,941, up 44% year over year.
- Revenue: $5.647 billion, up 55% year over year — both all‑time highs for the company.
- Net income: $263 million, with a 4.7% net margin, up from 4.0% a year earlier.
- Adjusted EBITDA: $637 million, an 11.3% margin, which Seeking Alpha characterizes as very strong conversion of gross profit into operating cash flow. [20]
- GAAP operating income: $552 million, with operating margin at 9.8%. [21]
Earlier, in Q2 2025, Carvana:
- Posted record revenue and units,
- Guided to full‑year 2025 Adjusted EBITDA of $2.0–2.2 billion, up from $1.38 billion in 2024. [22]
These results and forward‑looking targets are central to bullish valuations: they suggest that Carvana is not just recovering, but scaling into a high‑margin, asset‑light auto retail platform.
Market Position and Growth Potential
Analysts are increasingly framing Carvana as an e‑commerce disruptor rather than a traditional car dealer:
- UBS recently initiated coverage with a “Buy” rating and a $450 price target, calling Carvana a “true disruptor” with a best‑in‑class online platform. [23]
- UBS estimates Carvana currently has about 1.5% of total U.S. used‑vehicle sales (around 3% of the retail segment), with potential to grow to 4% by 2030 and possibly 8% over a longer horizon as more car buying moves online. [24]
- Today, only about 2% of used‑vehicle sales occur online, leaving substantial headroom if consumer behavior continues to shift. [25]
At the same time, Carvana faces rising competition, including Amazon Autos, which began selling new and used vehicles in late 2024 and has since partnered with brands like Hyundai, Hertz and Ford. [26]
Analyst Ratings, Price Targets and Stock Forecast (as of December 8, 2025)
Wall Street is broadly positive on Carvana, but price targets and risk assessments vary widely.
Overall consensus
Across several data providers:
- Consensus rating: generally a “Buy” or “Moderate Buy”.
- Average 12‑month price target: clustered in the mid‑$420s per share.
With the stock currently near $454, Carvana is trading above the average Street target, implying that many analysts see limited upside or modest downside over the next 12 months from today’s levels, even while maintaining Buy ratings.
Notable recent moves
Recent analyst actions tied directly to today’s S&P 500 news include:
- Bank of America (BofA):
- UBS:
- Initiated with Buy and a $450 target, emphasizing Carvana’s differentiated online experience and runway in the digitizing auto market. [34]
- Wedbush:
- Upgraded the stock from Neutral to Outperform in late November and raised its target to $400, warning shorts not to underestimate the turnaround. [35]
- Royal Bank of Canada (RBC):
- Reiterated Outperform with a $460 target. [36]
Data compiled by Benzinga and others shows a high estimate around $500 and a low around $275–330, underscoring how sharply opinions diverge on what Carvana is worth. [37]
Several commentary pieces (including CoinCentral and StockAnalysis‑linked discussions) stress that while fundamentals are improving, the valuation already discounts a great deal of future growth, leading some analysts to describe upside from here as “limited” after the recent surge. [38]
Valuation, Short Interest and Sentiment: Why Skeptics Haven’t Disappeared
Rich valuation
Reuters points out that Carvana trades at roughly 57.4x forward earnings, with a market cap near $87 billion, now higher than long‑established automakers like Ford and GM. [39]
Other valuation snapshots show:
- EV / EBITDA multiple around 50x on trailing numbers. [40]
- Price‑to‑sales ratio above 5x, based on 2025 revenue run‑rate. [41]
For a cyclical, capital‑intensive industry, these are high multiples, justified only if Carvana maintains rapid growth, strong margins and a durable competitive moat.
Short interest remains meaningful
Even after the massive squeeze of 2022–2023, Carvana is still a popular battleground stock:
- As of mid‑November 2025, short interest was about 11.5 million shares, roughly 5% of shares outstanding and around 8% of the float, with a days‑to‑cover ratio of roughly 3–4 days. [42]
That’s far below the 55% of float shorted at the height of the bear case in 2022, but it’s still enough to fuel volatility when positive catalysts — like today’s S&P 500 news — hit the tape. [43]
Social sentiment and skepticism
Not all market participants are convinced by the rally:
- A 24/7 Wall St piece notes that some retail traders on Reddit and X describe the S&P 500 inclusion as “one of the greatest market manipulations in history,” even as the stock jumps around 10% on pre‑market headlines. [44]
- Short‑focused commentary continues to question the sustainability of Carvana’s financing model and the durability of demand in a potentially slowing economy, though many of the most dire bankruptcy arguments have been blunted by recent earnings and debt deals. [45]
In other words, belief in the turnaround is high, but so is skepticism — fertile ground for large price swings in both directions.
Key Risks for Carvana Stock
Even bullish research notes emphasize several risks:
- Macro and credit risk
Carvana’s business is sensitive to interest rates, credit availability and used‑vehicle pricing. A deterioration in consumer credit quality or tighter auto‑loan markets could pressure sales and financing margins. [46] - High leverage
While debt has come down, Carvana still carries billions of dollars in debt and remains exposed to refinancing and liquidity risk if conditions worsen. [47] - Competitive intensity
- Execution risk at scale
Running a nationwide, inventory‑heavy, logistics‑intensive e‑commerce auto business is operationally complex. Any missteps in reconditioning capacity, inventory management or customer experience could quickly erode margins and confidence. [50] - Valuation risk
With the stock ahead of consensus price targets and trading at premium multiples, any disappointment in growth or margins could trigger sharp pullbacks as both longs and shorts reposition. [51]
What to Watch Next for CVNA
For investors and traders following Carvana after today’s spike, the next key milestones and data points include:
- Index inclusion date (December 22, 2025):
- How much incremental volume comes from index funds and ETFs.
- Whether there is a “buy the rumor, sell the news” reaction once passive buying is complete. [52]
- Q4 2025 and 2026 guidance:
Analysts will scrutinize whether Carvana can sustain double‑digit unit growth, double‑digit EBITDA margins, and further reduce leverage. [53] - Market‑share data vs. CarMax and emerging rivals:
Third‑party data cited by Barron’s already points to strong unit growth and suggests Carvana could surpass CarMax in quarterly sales by 2026 if current trends continue. [54] - Short interest trends and options positioning:
Changes in short interest, days‑to‑cover and put/call ratios will indicate whether bears are backing off or doubling down at these prices. [55]
Bottom Line
As of December 8, 2025, Carvana’s story is a rare combination of:
- Spectacular share‑price recovery,
- Real operational and financial improvement, and
- High‑stakes debate over valuation and sustainability.
The immediate driver of today’s move is clear: S&P 500 inclusion and the wave of index‑driven demand that comes with it. Underneath that, however, is a business that has gone from crisis to profitability, with a growing footprint in a still‑nascent online used‑car market — and a stock price that already bakes in a lot of success. [56]
References
1. www.reuters.com, 2. www.reuters.com, 3. www.investors.com, 4. www.barrons.com, 5. www.reuters.com, 6. www.barrons.com, 7. www.reuters.com, 8. 247wallst.com, 9. www.reuters.com, 10. www.barrons.com, 11. www.tradingview.com, 12. seekingalpha.com, 13. www.reuters.com, 14. investors.carvana.com, 15. companiesmarketcap.com, 16. www.barrons.com, 17. investors.carvana.com, 18. investors.carvana.com, 19. investors.carvana.com, 20. investors.carvana.com, 21. www.fool.com, 22. www.carvana.com, 23. www.marketwatch.com, 24. www.marketwatch.com, 25. www.marketwatch.com, 26. www.marketwatch.com, 27. www.marketbeat.com, 28. www.investing.com, 29. www.marketbeat.com, 30. www.marketwatch.com, 31. www.zacks.com, 32. www.barrons.com, 33. 247wallst.com, 34. www.marketwatch.com, 35. finance.yahoo.com, 36. www.marketbeat.com, 37. www.gurufocus.com, 38. coincentral.com, 39. www.reuters.com, 40. finviz.com, 41. finviz.com, 42. www.marketbeat.com, 43. seekingalpha.com, 44. 247wallst.com, 45. www.ft.com, 46. www.sec.gov, 47. companiesmarketcap.com, 48. www.barrons.com, 49. www.marketwatch.com, 50. investors.carvana.com, 51. stockanalysis.com, 52. www.reuters.com, 53. investors.carvana.com, 54. www.barrons.com, 55. stockanalysis.com, 56. www.reuters.com
