New York, January 22, 2026, 15:07 EST — Regular session
- Lemonade shares climbed about 13% in afternoon trade, extending Wednesday’s rally
- The insurer unveiled “Autonomous Car” coverage that prices Tesla Full Self-Driving miles at roughly half the human-driven rate
- Traders are watching the Arizona launch next week for early demand and claims signals
Lemonade, Inc. shares were up 12.6% at $96.13 on Thursday afternoon, after the insurer said it would slash per-mile rates for Tesla drivers when the automaker’s Full Self-Driving software is engaged. The stock hit an intraday high of $99.88 and traded as low as $86.86.
The jump matters because it ties Lemonade’s car insurance pitch directly to a stream of vehicle data, right as investors hunt for companies that can price driver-assist risk with something more than broad averages.
It is also the latest test of whether usage-based auto insurance can turn new sensors and software into lower claims, not just lower prices. Pay-per-mile, put simply, charges drivers based on how much they drive, rather than a flat premium.
Lemonade said its new “Lemonade Autonomous Car insurance” cuts per-mile rates for FSD-engaged driving by about 50% and could fall further as Tesla updates its software. “Traditional insurers treat a Tesla like any other car, and AI like any other driver,” co-founder and president Shai Wininger said, arguing that vehicles “that see 360 degrees” should not be priced like human drivers. 1
Wininger told Reuters the company is using Tesla telemetry to separate human-driven miles from FSD-driven miles, and said the Tesla data combined with Lemonade’s own insurance data showed FSD made driving about two times safer for the average driver. Tesla already sells its own insurance and offers a monthly discount of up to 10% for drivers who use FSD for more than half their miles, Reuters reported; the U.S. auto safety regulator has also investigated crashes involving FSD. 2
A separate Schedule 13G filing showed JPMorgan Chase & Co. reported beneficial ownership of 4,482,950 Lemonade shares, or 5.9% of the class, as of Dec. 31, 2025. 3
Another filing on Thursday showed officer John Sheldon Peters filed a Form 144 notice for a proposed sale of 9,000 Lemonade shares, with an approximate sale date of Jan. 22. 4
But the trade has a catch. If the safety gap between assisted and human driving proves narrower in real-world claims than Lemonade expects, the “cheaper miles” could become expensive miles fast, and pricing would need to move back up.
For now, the market is watching the first rollout: Lemonade said Tesla owners can start getting quotes for the product ahead of an Arizona launch on Jan. 26, with Oregon slated for next month. 5
