Tesla, Inc. (NASDAQ: TSLA) heads into Tuesday’s U.S. session after a volatile Monday that mixed a sharp Wall Street downgrade, aggressive new buyer incentives, and a major production milestone in China. Investors now have to decide whether the pullback is the start of a deeper reset in expectations or just another dip in a famously choppy stock.
Below is a structured look at what happened after the bell on December 8, 2025, and the key things to watch before the opening bell on December 9, 2025.
1. Where Tesla Stock Stands After Monday’s Close
Price action and volume
On Monday, December 8, Tesla shares fell roughly 3–4%, finishing the regular session just under $440 per share after trading between about $435 and $450. Daily volume was heavy at around 56–57 million shares, well above many recent sessions, underscoring how closely traders were watching the Morgan Stanley call and broader AI sentiment. [1]
Real‑time feeds shortly after the bell showed Tesla changing hands near $440 in the extended session (around 21:04 UTC), clawing back a small fraction of the intraday loss but leaving the stock clearly lower on the day.
Over the last couple of weeks, Tesla had actually been grinding higher: one analysis notes gains of about 7% in each of the prior two five‑day stretches, making Monday’s move a notable break in short‑term momentum. [2]
Bigger picture: valuation and range
Even after the pullback, Tesla is:
- Trading in a 52‑week range of roughly $214 to $489, hovering well below its 52‑week high but far above last year’s lows. [3]
- Up high single digits year‑to‑date in 2025, yet lagging the broader S&P 500, which has gained more than that over the same period. [4]
- Valued at well over 200× projected earnings for the next 12 months, making it one of the most expensive names in the S&P 500 on a forward P/E basis. [5]
Analyst target ranges also show how polarizing TSLA remains. A 24/7 Wall St. survey pegs the median 12‑month price target around $384, with a range that stretches from roughly $20 to $600 per share. [6] Trading platforms aggregating Wall Street forecasts show a similar spread, with some bulls still targeting $600 while the most bearish forecasts sit near $120. [7]
2. The Big Catalyst: Morgan Stanley’s Downgrade and the ‘Physical AI’ Debate
From Overweight to Equal‑Weight
The single biggest driver of Monday’s sell‑off was a rating cut from Morgan Stanley, historically one of Tesla’s more vocal supporters.
- The bank downgraded TSLA from “Overweight” to “Equal‑Weight” (roughly “Buy” to “Hold”). [8]
- At the same time, it raised its price target from $410 to $425, essentially saying the stock has largely run up to what it considers fair value. [9]
New lead analyst Andrew Percoco framed Tesla as still deserving a premium valuation thanks to its leadership in EVs, manufacturing, renewable energy, and “real‑world AI,” but warned that enthusiasm around those AI and robotics businesses is now “largely in the price.” [10]
Several outlets, from Bloomberg to Investopedia, highlighted that Tesla’s valuation now rivals or exceeds many other AI‑themed names, with the stock trading at about 210× expected earnings—among the priciest in the S&P 500. [11]
How Morgan Stanley values Tesla’s business pieces
Crucially for investors, Morgan Stanley laid out a sum‑of‑the‑parts framework for its $425 target, carving Tesla into five big buckets: [12]
- EV business (core auto):$55 per share, down from a prior $75 estimate, reflecting reduced volume and pricing assumptions through 2040.
- Network services:$145 per share, including Full Self‑Driving (FSD) software, the Supercharger network, and service operations.
- Energy business:$40 per share, mostly Megapack and Powerwall.
- Mobility/robotaxis:$125 per share, assuming Tesla expands self‑driving fleets across multiple markets.
- Humanoid robots (Optimus):$60 per share, but with a substantial probability discount due to execution risk.
In other words, roughly three‑quarters of the price target now comes from non‑traditional auto segments (software, energy, robotaxis and robotics), not from selling cars.
The bank also cut its auto volume forecasts, now modeling around 1.6 million vehicle deliveries in 2026, a figure it says is meaningfully below Street consensus given slower EV adoption and heavy competition from Chinese players. [13]
Expected impact: more volatility, not collapse
Morgan Stanley’s team signaled they still believe in Tesla’s long‑term AI and robotics potential, but expect:
- A “choppy” 12 months as the EV business struggles with margins and competition.
- A meaningful risk that Tesla misses near‑term earnings estimates if price cuts and incentives outweigh efficiency gains. [14]
That view was echoed across other commentary sites and financial media on Monday, helping push the stock down about 4% intraday as traders repositioned around the new $425 line in the sand. [15]
3. Demand vs. Margins: Tesla’s Aggressive Year‑End Incentives
While Wall Street frets about valuation, Tesla is busy pulling demand levers heading into year‑end.
0% APR, $0 down, and free upgrades
On Monday morning, Tesla‑focused outlets detailed a new wave of U.S. buyer incentives rolling out across the site and inventory pages: [16]
- 0% APR financing for up to 72 months on select Model 3 and Model Y configurations (especially the high‑volume Model Y standard range).
- $0 down leases across much of the S3XY lineup, significantly lowering the upfront cost of getting into a Tesla.
- A “free upgrade” badge on many inventory cars, effectively waiving the cost of paid options such as premium paint colors, larger wheels, or upgraded interiors—often worth $1,000–$2,500 per vehicle.
Tesla’s own promotional copy urges buyers to take delivery by December 31, 2025 to access these limited‑time offers, underscoring the company’s push to maximize Q4 deliveries.
These incentives are described by seasoned Tesla watchers as some of the most aggressive end‑of‑year deals the company has offered in years, prompted in part by the expiration of a major U.S. EV tax credit in Q3 that pulled demand forward and left more inventory on lots in Q4. [17]
What it means for the stock
For shareholders, this cuts both ways:
- Bullish angle:
Stronger promotions could help Tesla defend or even grow volumes, supporting the case that it can continue leading EV adoption and keep factories like Shanghai and Austin running near capacity. - Bearish angle:
Every extra dollar knocked off financing or options pressures automotive gross margins, which have already been squeezed by multiple rounds of price cuts and mix shifts. Analysts have repeatedly warned that auto profits are under pressure even as Tesla invests heavily in AI, FSD and robotics. [18]
Heading into Tuesday’s open, traders will be watching for any early data points—delivery estimates, wait‑time changes or commentary from EV trackers—showing whether these deals are primarily boosting volume or simply sacrificing margin to hold the line.
4. Scale and Cost: Shanghai’s 4 Millionth Vehicle
Away from Wall Street’s spreadsheets, Tesla notched a symbolic milestone on Monday in China.
According to China Daily, Tesla’s Shanghai Gigafactory produced its 4 millionth vehicle on December 8, a Model Y L, cementing the plant’s status as the company’s largest global production hub. [19]
Key details from the report:
- The Shanghai plant accounts for about half of Tesla’s global production capacity and serves as its primary export base.
- The factory can reportedly build a car roughly every 30 seconds, thanks to tightly integrated stamping, welding, painting and final assembly under one roof.
- Localization has reached around 95%, with over 400 tier‑1 suppliers, more than 60 of which now feed Tesla’s global operations.
- Tesla’s Shanghai Megafactory—its first energy‑storage plant outside the U.S.—began operating in early 2025, targeting around 10,000 Megapack units per year (about 40 GWh of storage). [20]
This milestone supports the bullish narrative on Tesla’s scale and cost advantage. High localization and manufacturing efficiency give Tesla more room to cut prices or offer incentives while still making money, especially in China and export markets.
At the same time, it highlights concentration risk: a big slice of Tesla’s capacity and supply chain is tied to China, where competition from local champions like BYD is intense and policy risk is non‑trivial. [21]
5. AI, Optimus and the Robotics Story: Hype vs. Reality
AI as a competitive moat
A new Gartner study covered by Reuters on Monday argued that by 2029 only about 5% of automakers will continue growing AI investment strongly, down from more than 95% today. The winners, Gartner says, will be companies with deep software expertise and long‑term AI focus—researchers explicitly name Tesla and BYD as tech‑driven rivals that legacy manufacturers such as Volkswagen are chasing. [22]
That backdrop supports the idea behind Morgan Stanley’s “Beyond the Wheel – Mapping Tesla’s Journey into Physical AI” thesis: Tesla isn’t just a carmaker; it’s an AI and robotics platform whose real value may come from software, robotaxis and humanoid robots.
Optimus takes a tumble
Reality, however, remains messy.
Over the weekend, video from Tesla’s “Autonomy Visualized” event at its Miami showroom went viral. In the clip, an Optimus humanoid robot appears to hand out water bottles before making a motion that looks like a person removing a VR headset—then promptly falls over, knocking items from a table. [23]
Coverage from EV and tech blogs has raised questions about:
- How much of Optimus’s behavior is teleoperated versus truly autonomous.
- Whether Tesla’s ambitious projections for deploying millions of robots in factories—and eventually homes—are realistic on the timelines investors are baking into the stock.
Morgan Stanley itself assigns around $60 per share of value to the humanoid robot segment but applies a 50% probability discount for execution risk, underscoring how speculative this part of the story remains. [24]
Despite the mishap, Tesla continues to invest heavily in Optimus and AI talent. One recent example: a senior Apple engineer, Yilun Chen, has reportedly joined Tesla’s Optimus team, a sign that the company is still pulling high‑profile talent into its robotics program. [25]
For Tuesday’s trade, the robotics narrative matters mainly at the sentiment level—it feeds the debate over whether Tesla is an over‑hyped AI proxy or legitimately the first “physical AI” platform at global scale.
6. Fundamentals Check: Where Tesla Stands Under the Hood
A comprehensive December 8 fundamental overview of Tesla highlights both strengths and growing pressure points: [26]
Growth engines
- Product lineup: Tesla continues to ship Model S, X, 3, Y, Cybertruck and Semi, while preparing a more affordable next‑gen platform (“Model 2” / “Model Q”) aimed at sub‑$30,000 price points.
- Energy storage: Tesla remains a top global player in battery energy storage systems (BESS), with Megapack deployments growing quickly and the Shanghai Megafactory ramping to around 20 GWh/year initially.
- R&D intensity: Over the twelve months to September 30, 2025, Tesla spent roughly $5.9 billion on R&D, up more than 35% year‑on‑year, much of it directed toward AI, FSD, Optimus and new vehicle platforms.
Competitive and market‑share pressures
At the same time:
- Tesla’s global EV market share is slipping as rivals in China, Europe and the U.S. roll out compelling alternatives. From January to August 2025, Tesla ranked third globally with about 7–8% of EV deliveries, behind BYD and Geely, and its European share has dropped sharply compared with early 2024. [27]
- In the United States, Tesla’s share is still dominant but trending lower—from nearly 49% to around 38% in 2025 as mainstream brands push aggressively into EVs. [28]
- Tesla’s brand and governance remain under scrutiny, with CEO Elon Musk’s political activity and massive pay packages frequently cited as risk factors by governance‑focused investors. [29]
This mixed fundamental picture is why Wall Street opinion is so split: Investopedia notes that among tracked analysts, ratings are roughly balanced between buys, holds and sells, and the average price target (~$388–$395) sits notably below Monday’s closing price. [30]
7. What to Watch Before the Opening Bell on December 9, 2025
With all of that in mind, here’s what investors and traders should be thinking about heading into Tuesday’s session.
1. Does the stock gravitate toward the new $425 target?
With Tesla closing in the mid‑$430s–$440s range after hours and Morgan Stanley’s new $425 target implying limited upside (and even slight downside) from here, early trading may test how aggressively the market wants to re‑anchor TSLA around that level. [31]
- A decisive move below the low‑$430s would suggest investors are taking the downgrade seriously and perhaps anticipating further estimate cuts.
- A rebound toward $455 (Friday’s close) would indicate traders see Monday’s sell‑off as an overreaction.
2. Follow‑through from other analysts
The Morgan Stanley call is influential enough that:
- Other brokers may update their Tesla models in coming days, potentially leading to additional downgrades or target cuts.
- Any high‑profile upgrades or fresh bullish notes arguing that the pullback is a buying opportunity could spark a strong reaction, especially given Tesla’s large retail base and heavy options market.
Watch for pre‑market research headlines and early commentary from well‑followed Tesla analysts on Tuesday.
3. Early read‑through on incentives
The new 0% APR, $0‑down and free‑upgrade offers only went live recently. Before the open and during Tuesday’s session, investors will be scanning for:
- Order and wait‑time chatter from Tesla forums, social media and EV‑tracker sites.
- Commentary on whether these incentives appear to be clearing inventory or simply adding pressure on margins with only modest volume impact.
If early signs point to strong take‑up, the market may lean more toward a “volume first, margin later” growth story. Weak response could fuel the narrative that Tesla is having to “beg” for demand, as one EV blog put it. [32]
4. Reaction to Shanghai and China exposure
The 4‑million‑vehicle milestone in Shanghai is a reminder that Tesla’s cost advantage is deeply tied to its Chinese operations. [33]
Things to watch:
- Any Chinese headlines around EV policy, tariffs or local competition that could affect sentiment toward Tesla’s China exposure.
- Whether analysts frame the Shanghai news as evidence of enduring scale advantage or as a sign Tesla is increasingly locked into a fiercely competitive market.
5. Macro backdrop: The Fed and AI bubble worries
Broad macro conditions matter a lot for high‑multiple, AI‑themed names like Tesla.
- A recent market note highlighted that futures markets are assigning around an 85–90% probability of a 25 bps Fed rate cut at the December 9–10 FOMC meeting, a backdrop that usually supports richly‑valued growth stocks. [34]
- At the same time, commentators from YouTubers to institutional strategists are warning about a potential AI‑driven bubble, often listing Tesla alongside names like Nvidia and big‑tech cloud players as core beneficiaries of the trade. [35]
If bond yields move sharply overnight or the market’s rate‑cut expectations change, Tesla could see outsized moves at the open.
6. Options, volatility and retail sentiment
TSLA remains one of the most actively traded options underlyings in the U.S., and Monday’s downgrade is likely to have:
- Pushed implied volatility higher as traders bought puts for protection and speculative calls for a rebound.
- Attracted heavy short‑term retail interest, especially among traders focusing on day‑to‑day momentum.
Expect wide intraday swings on Tuesday, even if the stock ultimately finishes near Monday’s after‑hours level.
8. Bottom Line: How to Frame Tesla Going Into December 9
Heading into Tuesday’s open, Tesla’s setup looks like this:
- Valuation check: One of its most influential bulls just shifted to a neutral stance, arguing that AI and robotics optionality is now mostly priced in at current levels.
- Execution pressure: Tesla is ramping incentives and leaning on Shanghai to push volume, while margins and market share face real headwinds in key regions.
- Optionality remains: The company still leads in EV scale, energy storage and real‑world AI investment, and is pulling in top talent and pouring billions into R&D.
- Volatility likely: With sentiment split, macro uncertainty high and options activity intense, day‑to‑day moves are more likely to be sharp than smooth.
For long‑term investors, the core question remains whether Tesla can turn its AI, FSD and robotics ambitions into durable, high‑margin cash flows fast enough to justify one of the richest valuations in global markets.
For short‑term traders, Tuesday is about watching how the stock behaves around the $425–$455 band, reading the tape on incentives and China headlines, and respecting the fact that TSLA can move several percentage points in either direction on very little news.
Important: This article is for informational and educational purposes only and is not investment advice. Tesla stock is volatile and risky; always do your own research and consider your risk tolerance or consult a licensed financial professional before making trading or investing decisions.
References
1. stockanalysis.com, 2. 247wallst.com, 3. www.nasdaq.com, 4. tokenist.com, 5. www.bloomberg.com, 6. 247wallst.com, 7. www.tradingview.com, 8. www.investopedia.com, 9. www.investopedia.com, 10. www.investopedia.com, 11. www.bloomberg.com, 12. www.investopedia.com, 13. tokenist.com, 14. www.investopedia.com, 15. www.investopedia.com, 16. electrek.co, 17. electrek.co, 18. www.investors.com, 19. www.chinadailyasia.com, 20. www.chinadailyasia.com, 21. markets.financialcontent.com, 22. www.reuters.com, 23. electrek.co, 24. tokenist.com, 25. www.notateslaapp.com, 26. markets.financialcontent.com, 27. markets.financialcontent.com, 28. markets.financialcontent.com, 29. markets.financialcontent.com, 30. www.investopedia.com, 31. www.investopedia.com, 32. insideevs.com, 33. www.chinadailyasia.com, 34. stocktwits.com, 35. fortune.com
