Tesla, Inc. (NASDAQ: TSLA) is waking up to a softer tone on Monday, December 8, 2025. In pre‑market trading the stock is hovering in the high $440s, roughly 1–2% below Friday’s close at $455, after a strong multi‑week run. [1]
The early pressure comes just as:
- Morgan Stanley’s new lead Tesla analyst downgrades the stock on valuation concerns. [2]
- Fresh data show Tesla gaining share in China even as that market cools. [3]
- A headline‑grabbing Optimus robot incident fuels fresh questions about autonomy. [4]
- A detailed new bull/base/bear forecast lays out one‑year and long‑term price paths. [5]
Here’s what traders and longer‑term investors need to know before the opening bell.
1. Where Tesla stock stands before the open
Price and recent performance
- Friday, Dec. 5 close: $455.00. [6]
- Pre‑market quotes early Monday: roughly $448–$450, down about 1–2% as different feeds show TSLA around $447.9–$449.9. [7]
- Over the last week, Tesla has climbed from the low $430s to mid‑$450s, with daily closes of $430–435 on Dec. 1–2, $446.7 on Dec. 3, $454.5 on Dec. 4, and $455 on Dec. 5. [8]
- TradingView notes the stock is up about 20% year‑to‑date and on track for a third straight annual gain, despite plenty of volatility. [9]
Valuation snapshot
MarketBeat data put Tesla’s market cap around $1.5 trillion, with a trailing P/E near 303x, a one‑year low of $214.25 and a one‑year high of $488.54. [10]
In other words, even after last year’s wobble, Tesla is still trading at:
- A premium multiple vs. traditional automakers.
- A valuation closer to high‑growth tech or AI names than to Detroit peers.
That lofty multiple is exactly what Monday’s big analyst call is about.
2. Morgan Stanley moves to the sidelines: downgrade with a twist
The headline this morning: Morgan Stanley has cut Tesla from “Overweight” (Buy) to “Equal‑weight” (Neutral) while raising its price target from $410 to $425 — about 6–7% below where the stock was trading before the downgrade. [11]
Key details from Morgan Stanley’s new lead Tesla analyst, Andrew Percoco:
- He has taken over coverage from Adam Jonas and immediately reset the rating to Neutral. [12]
- He still calls Tesla a “clear global leader” in EVs, manufacturing, renewable energy and real‑world AI, but argues that high expectations for AI and non‑auto businesses now leave the stock near fair value. [13]
- He expects a “choppy trading environment” over the next 12 months, with downside risk to Street earnings estimates. [14]
A detailed sum‑of‑the‑parts valuation
Percoco’s note is unusually explicit about where he thinks Tesla’s value actually comes from: [15]
- Tesla Auto: cut from $75 to $55 per share, reflecting a weaker volume outlook, especially in the U.S.
- He trims 2026 volume estimates by 10.5% and total deliveries through 2040 by 18.5%, and now sits about 13% below Street consensus on 2026 auto volumes.
- Humanoid (Optimus): new in the framework, valued at $60 per share, reflecting Tesla’s perceived edge in real‑world AI, manufacturing and data.
- Network Services (FSD & software): the “crown jewel”, valued at $145 per share, based on the belief that Tesla’s personal autonomous driving platform offers a sustained competitive advantage.
- Tesla Mobility (robotaxi):$125 per share tied to robotaxi opportunities.
- Energy:$40 per share.
That structure matters: the stock is now being explicitly valued less as a carmaker and more as a software, robotaxi and humanoid‑robot platform — which helps explain why bulls and bears can look at the same company and see wildly different outcomes.
Morgan Stanley also points out that at current levels Tesla trades at about 30x projected 2030 EBITDA (48x on their own estimates), a multiple they see as rich given softer EV demand and competitive risk. [16]
Pre‑market takeaway: For short‑term traders, the downgrade gives bears a clean headline to lean on into the open, even though the target hike and explicit value for Optimus and FSD will be used by longer‑term bulls as support.
3. China: Tesla gains share in a shrinking market
Overnight, new data from the China Passenger Car Association (CPCA) and fresh commentary from TipRanks highlight an important twist: China’s overall car market is cooling, but Tesla is growing again there. [17]
According to the latest report:
- China passenger car sales fell for a second straight month in November, down about 8.5% year‑over‑year to 2.24 million units. [18]
- Tesla’s China sales rose 9.9% in the same month.
- Main rival BYD’s EV and hybrid sales fell 5.3% year‑over‑year, its third consecutive monthly decline. [19]
Tesla’s broader Chinese EV rivals (Li Auto, NIO, Xpeng) still grew shipments, but at their slowest growth rate of the year, underscoring how competitive and mature the market is becoming. [20]
Shanghai hits 4 million vehicles
Adding to the China narrative, Tesla’s Shanghai Gigafactory just produced its four‑millionth China‑made vehicle, specifically a Starlight Gold Model Y L. [21]
- Shanghai is Tesla’s largest manufacturing site globally, and the jump from 3 to 4 million units took under 14 months, signaling a sustained ramp‑up in capacity. [22]
Europe still wobbly
The same TipRanks piece notes that while China is stabilizing for Tesla, Europe remains volatile:
- Tesla’s sales in key European markets like France, Denmark and Sweden fell more than 50% in November.
- In response, Tesla has rolled out cheaper “standard” versions of the Model 3 and Model Y in Europe in recent months to stimulate demand. [23]
Pre‑market takeaway: Monday’s China news is a clear positive data point in Tesla’s most important growth market, partly offsetting the Morgan Stanley downgrade. But weakness in Europe reinforces the idea that EV demand is becoming more patchy by region.
4. Optimus and the autonomy story: hype vs. reality on display
The Optimus humanoid robot — a big piece of Tesla’s long‑term valuation story — is also in the headlines this morning for less‑than‑flattering reasons.
At Tesla’s “Autonomy Visualized” event in Miami over the weekend, video surfaced of an Optimus robot: [24]
- Standing behind a counter with water bottles.
- Appearing to mime taking off a headset — even though it wasn’t wearing one.
- Then falling to the floor and seemingly shutting down.
The clip fueled renewed speculation that the robot was being teleoperated (remote‑controlled) rather than acting autonomously. Popular tech YouTuber JerryRigEverything questioned how Tesla will find enough teleoperators if both robotaxis and robots require human overseers, and suggested 2026 could be a “tough year” for Tesla. [25]
At the same time, Tesla has recently showcased clips of Optimus running, performing martial‑arts‑like moves and appearing at a movie premiere, with Elon Musk insisting those demonstrations were driven by AI rather than remote control. [26]
Musk has repeatedly said Optimus could account for “around 80%” of Tesla’s future value, framing it as a key driver behind long‑term valuation. [27]
Why this matters for the stock today
- Morgan Stanley’s SOTP assigns $60 per share to Optimus and $145 per share to Network Services (including FSD), meaning nearly half their Tesla valuation rests on software and robots. [28]
- Any sign that the tech is further from full autonomy than advertised could make the market more sensitive to negative headlines like the Miami incident.
- Critics such as Michael Burry continue to call Tesla’s market cap “ridiculously overvalued,” citing exactly this disconnect between narrative and current fundamentals. [29]
For traders, Optimus is a double‑edged sword: it provides upside optionality that justifies aggressive bullish scenarios — and also gives skeptics endless fodder when demonstrations go wrong.
5. Fresh forecasts: bull, base and bear cases for TSLA
A new 24/7 Wall St. forecast out this morning lays out three clear scenarios for Tesla’s share price, anchored around robotaxis, Cybertruck, and Optimus. [30]
Bull case (12‑month focus)
- Assumes Tesla successfully ramps Cybertruck/“Cybercab” as a robotaxi platform, with robust progress in full self‑driving and early traction for Optimus.
- References ARK Invest’s multi‑trillion‑dollar robotaxi opportunity and Wedbush’s bullish outlook, concluding that a bull‑case one‑year target around $550 per share — roughly 34% above current levels — is plausible if execution is strong. [31]
Bear case
- Emphasizes recalls (notably a near‑full Cybertruck recall), safety concerns and negative press, including studies showing Tesla having a higher fatal accident rate than the average automaker (around 5.6 vs. 2.8 deaths per billion miles in one cited report). [32]
- Highlights intensifying competition, including a Jeff Bezos‑backed EV startup targeting ~$30,000 trucks/SUVs as an “anti‑Tesla” brand. [33]
- Points to heavy insider selling and falling institutional ownership in some datasets, with more than 100 institutions said to have fully exited positions over the past year. [34]
Base case
- Notes that Wall Street’s median 12‑month target is about $383.5, implying mid‑teens downside from current prices. [35]
- High‑end Street targets approach $600, while the lowest sits below $20, reflecting massive dispersion in expectations. [36]
- The author suggests something near $300 per share as “fair value” under moderate assumptions, given Tesla’s forward P/E north of 200x and forward price‑to‑sales near 15x. [37]
Consensus snapshot across data providers
Across the main aggregators, the picture is strikingly similar:
- MarketBeat:
- 1 Strong Buy, 21 Buy, 13 Hold, 9 Sell ratings.
- Consensus rating: Hold, with an average target around $398.92. [38]
- TipRanks:
- 12 Buys, 12 Holds, 10 Sells over the last three months.
- Average target $383.54, about 16% below current levels. [39]
- Public.com:
- Puts Tesla’s 12‑month target near $378.50, again implying mild downside from today’s price. [40]
In short, Wall Street is broadly neutral: analysts respect Tesla’s technology and optionality but, on average, do not see the current price as a bargain.
6. Fundamentals and upcoming catalysts
Latest earnings
Recent filings and institutional‑holding notes recap Tesla’s October quarter: [41]
- EPS: $0.50 vs. $0.48 expected.
- Revenue: $28.10 billion vs. $24.98 billion expected, up 11.6% year‑over‑year.
- Net margin around 5.5% and return on equity about 6.6% — solid but far from the hyper‑profitable narratives some bulls envision.
Yahoo Finance’s consensus estimates show: [42]
- Q4 2025 EPS: ~$0.45.
- Full‑year 2025 EPS: ~$1.65.
- 2026 EPS: ~$2.27 across ~35 analysts.
Those numbers are important when you line them up against a $450‑ish share price and a trillion‑plus market cap.
Q4 deliveries and the “Santa rally” story
A TradingView breakdown highlights that analysts expect Q4 deliveries between about 507,000 and 512,000 vehicles, putting Tesla on track to deliver a bit over 2 million cars in 2025. [43]
- Historically, Tesla has often rallied into year‑end, and the stock has finished higher in more than half of all Decembers since its IPO. [44]
- With major indexes near record highs and U.S. futures slightly green heading into this week’s Fed meeting, there is a broader risk‑on backdrop that could support high‑beta names like TSLA — if company‑specific news cooperates. [45]
Official Q4 delivery numbers are due in early January and will likely be the next big binary catalyst after today’s Morgan Stanley move.
7. Institutional and insider flows: big rotation under the surface
Several new 13F‑style filings hitting the tape this morning show large institutions actively reshuffling Tesla exposure: [46]
- Winslow Capital Management
- Trimmed its Tesla position by 14.2% in Q2, selling 231,318 shares.
- Still holds about 1.4 million shares (~$444 million), making TSLA its 22nd‑largest position and roughly 1.5% of the fund. [47]
- Temasek Holdings (Singapore sovereign investor)
- Cut its Tesla stake by 68.2%, selling 74,940 shares and retaining 34,950 shares worth about $11.1 million. [48]
- Other institutions (Norges Bank, Vanguard, Geode, Legal & General, Amundi, Kingstone Capital and others) have raised or initiated sizable positions, leaving institutional investors collectively owning well over half of Tesla’s float in most datasets. [49]
On the insider side:
- Recent filings show Director James Murdoch and SVP Xiaotong Zhu selling significant share blocks in September, with insiders collectively owning just under 20% of the company. [50]
- 24/7 Wall St., using separate data, notes no insider share purchases in the last three months and only one in the past year, alongside multiple insider sales and a reported drop in institutional ownership in that dataset. [51]
Pre‑market takeaway: The filings paint a picture of rotation rather than capitulation — some big funds are taking profits after the rally while others are leaning into the long‑term AI/robotics narrative.
8. Crypto side‑note: Dogecoin quietly edges closer to Tesla
On the more speculative end of today’s news flow, CoinCentral reports that Tesla’s website code now includes Dogecoin (DOGE) as a payment option, potentially enabling purchases of cars like the Model 3 and Cybertruck with the meme coin. [52]
- DOGE network activity has spiked to three‑month highs, with large “whale” wallets accumulating roughly 480 million tokens in early December. [53]
- Tesla has already experimented with accepting Dogecoin for some merchandise; code‑level support for vehicle payments would broaden that experiment if and when it’s activated.
This isn’t a major fundamental shift by itself, but it reinforces Tesla’s brand as a high‑beta, culture‑driven asset — something that tends to amplify volatility around events like today’s downgrade.
9. Macro backdrop: Fed week and risk appetite
Beyond Tesla‑specific headlines, U.S. equity futures are modestly higher this morning as traders look ahead to the Federal Open Market Committee meeting that begins December 9. [54]
- Nasdaq 100, S&P 500 and Dow futures were up around 0.25%, 0.16% and 0.02% respectively early Monday. [55]
- The S&P 500 sits less than 1% below its all‑time intraday high after a second consecutive positive week. [56]
For Tesla, a dovish‑leaning Fed would help justify higher multiples on long‑duration growth stories; a hawkish surprise could do the opposite.
10. What to watch in Tesla stock today
Putting it all together, here are the key lenses for TSLA as the market opens on December 8, 2025:
- Reaction to the Morgan Stanley downgrade
- Does the stock hold the $445–$450 area, or do sellers push it back toward the low $430s, where it traded earlier this month? [57]
- Watch volume: heavy selling on the downgrade would suggest institutions taking the cue; lighter action would imply much of the news was already priced in.
- China narrative vs. Europe weakness
- The 9.9% November sales growth in China against an 8.5% market decline is a clear relative win. [58]
- Ongoing softness in Europe and fresh price cuts there may keep margins and demand under scrutiny.
- Optimus and autonomy sentiment
- The Miami incident is more about optics than financials, but it goes straight to the heart of Tesla’s valuation story in AI and robotics. [59]
- Watch how much weight traders give to Morgan Stanley’s big valuation allocations for FSD/Optimus vs. viral videos questioning the tech.
- Analyst and media narrative
- Expect a wave of commentary recapping the bull/base/bear price paths, with bulls leaning on the $550 bull‑case and bears highlighting the median target near $380 and the possibility of much lower prices in a worst‑case scenario. [60]
- Flows & options
- TSLA remains one of the most liquid options names; intraday moves can be amplified by dealer hedging and short‑dated call/put activity — especially on a day with a fresh high‑profile downgrade and macro risk events ahead.
- Countdown to Q4 deliveries
- If markets remain constructive and delivery expectations (roughly 507k–512k units) hold, the stock could stay pinned near the upper end of its 52‑week range into early January. A big miss or beat there will likely matter more than today’s downgrade in hindsight. [61]
Final word
Tesla enters Monday’s session as one of the most debated stocks in the world:
- Bulls will argue that Morgan Stanley’s downgrade actually validates the huge optionality in humanoid robots, FSD and network services — and that China’s latest numbers plus the Shanghai milestone show the EV engine is far from stalling. [62]
- Bears will point to the rich valuation, insider selling, institutional trimming, Europe slowdown, safety controversies and eye‑catching incidents like the Optimus fall as signs that expectations have outrun reality. [63]
References
1. www.marketwatch.com, 2. www.tipranks.com, 3. www.tipranks.com, 4. www.benzinga.com, 5. 247wallst.com, 6. www.marketwatch.com, 7. www.marketwatch.com, 8. www.investing.com, 9. www.tradingview.com, 10. www.marketbeat.com, 11. www.tipranks.com, 12. www.tipranks.com, 13. www.tipranks.com, 14. www.tipranks.com, 15. www.tipranks.com, 16. www.tipranks.com, 17. www.tipranks.com, 18. www.tipranks.com, 19. www.tipranks.com, 20. www.tipranks.com, 21. seekingalpha.com, 22. seekingalpha.com, 23. www.tipranks.com, 24. www.benzinga.com, 25. www.benzinga.com, 26. www.benzinga.com, 27. www.benzinga.com, 28. www.tipranks.com, 29. www.benzinga.com, 30. 247wallst.com, 31. 247wallst.com, 32. 247wallst.com, 33. 247wallst.com, 34. 247wallst.com, 35. 247wallst.com, 36. 247wallst.com, 37. 247wallst.com, 38. www.marketbeat.com, 39. www.tipranks.com, 40. public.com, 41. www.marketbeat.com, 42. finance.yahoo.com, 43. www.tradingview.com, 44. www.tradingview.com, 45. www.tipranks.com, 46. www.marketbeat.com, 47. www.marketbeat.com, 48. www.marketbeat.com, 49. www.marketbeat.com, 50. www.marketbeat.com, 51. 247wallst.com, 52. coincentral.com, 53. coincentral.com, 54. www.tipranks.com, 55. www.tipranks.com, 56. www.tipranks.com, 57. www.investing.com, 58. www.tipranks.com, 59. www.benzinga.com, 60. 247wallst.com, 61. www.tradingview.com, 62. www.tipranks.com, 63. www.marketbeat.com
