Carvana (NYSE:CVNA) Shares Drop After Outlook Points to Weaker Profit Expansion in Second Half

Carvana Co. shares surged 8.3% Tuesday after a softer U.S. inflation print sent Treasury yields sliding, which offered more support to the debt-reliant used-car platform than to the general market or rival dealerships. Carvana finished at $70.38, ahead of the S&P 500 by 7.9 points. The gain looked tied to macro factors.

Carvana Co. slipped 2.58% to $77.94 on Friday, its first session after the share split, with 6.96 million shares changing hands. The move puts a lower sticker price on one of the market’s most-watched turnaround names, but doesn’t alter the company’s fundamental pitch to investors.

Carvana’s five-for-one stock split became effective Thursday, putting the online used-car dealer’s strong recovery right back in the market’s sights. The Class A shares are set to start trading split-adjusted on the New York Stock Exchange when markets open Friday, according to a securities filing. The forward split increases share count and reduces the price per share, but investors’ stakes remain unchanged.

Carvana Co. shares edged up Tuesday, closing 0.85% higher at $477.75. The stock fluctuated between $463.49 and $484.42 during trading. In after-hours, it remained close to $477.7.

Carvana Co shares rose on Wednesday after a filing showed The Vanguard Group held an 11.86% stake in the online used-car retailer at the end of 2025. The stock closed up about 2.4% at $450.78 and was up around 0.1% at $451.26 in extended trading as of 7:54 p.m. ET. MarketBeat

Carvana Co shares closed down 1.7% at $422.02 on Wednesday, the last U.S. trading session of 2025, as investors wrapped up a holiday-shortened week before Wall Street’s New Year’s Day closure. The stock traded between $421.95 and $430.30.

Carvana Co. heads into the final week of 2025 with investors debating a familiar question: after a blockbuster year, does the rally still have room to run in 2026—or is the stock priced for perfection?

Carvana Co. heads into the final full trading week of 2025 with a familiar mix of ingredients: a still-hot momentum narrative, a newly “institutionalized” shareholder base after its S&P 500 inclusion, and the kind of valuation that makes both bulls and bears speak in italics.

Carvana Co. is heading into the final trading days of 2025 with investors debating a familiar question—after a blockbuster comeback year and a major index milestone, is there still meaningful upside left for 2026, or is the stock entering a digestion phase where execution matters more than momentum?

Carvana Co. finished the Christmas Eve session modestly higher and traded nearly flat in after-hours, a fitting setup for a stock that has been one of 2025’s most talked-about consumer names. Shares closed at $441.57 on Dec. 24, up just under 1%, and were hovering around $441.5 in extended-hours quotes later in the day. Google

Carvana Co. finished Tuesday’s regular session higher and then held steady in the first stretch of after-hours trading—an important “reset” day for a stock that’s been swinging sharply around its newly effective S&P 500 inclusion.